1. A trade group's response on UK crypto regulation
CryptoUK, the main trade association for the United Kingdom's crypto industry, has asked the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to make clear that developers of decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols and participants in their governance are not treated as regulated firms by default. The request came in a response on UK crypto regulation submitted on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, the day the regulator's consultation closed.
The group, which says it represents more than 150 crypto companies, published the document a day after filing it. The response addresses consultation paper CP26/36, in which the FCA proposes guidance on the perimeter of the country's crypto regime, meaning the boundary that separates activities requiring authorization from those that do not.
CryptoUK's overall verdict was favorable. It said it broadly supports the draft. Its objections are concentrated on specific passages where, in its view, the guidance reaches beyond what the underlying legislation provides, and on the position of people who build and maintain decentralized software.
2. What is the FCA's perimeter guidance?
Perimeter guidance is the FCA's explanation of which activities fall inside the scope of regulation and therefore require a firm to be authorized. The regulator maintains this material in its Perimeter Guidance Manual, known as PERG, and CP26/36 proposes amendments to that manual for crypto.
The changes are intended to reflect the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Cryptoassets) (Miscellaneous Amendments) Regulations 2026, amendments the government laid in September. In the UK system, legislation defines the regulated activities, and the FCA's guidance sets out how the regulator reads those definitions in practice. Guidance of this kind does not create the law, but it shapes how companies assess whether they need permission to operate.
That is why the wording matters to the industry. A business that sits outside the perimeter can operate without FCA authorization for that activity. One that sits inside must apply, meet the regulator's standards and accept ongoing supervision. Where the guidance draws the line determines which side a given company, service or individual falls on.
The FCA aims to publish the final version of the guidance in January 2027.
3. The case for DeFi developers and governance participants
Decentralized finance is where the perimeter question is hardest to answer. DeFi protocols are software systems that carry out financial functions such as trading or lending through code, often with changes decided by holders of governance tokens instead of a conventional management team. The people who write that code, patch its vulnerabilities or vote on its parameters may have no role in handling customer funds or running a service in the traditional sense.
CryptoUK asked the regulator to state this distinction explicitly. In its words, "Software development, maintenance, security work and participation in decentralised governance should not, by themselves," establish a regulated activity.
The group presented this as consistent with the FCA's own thinking, not as a departure from it. The regulator has described a "clear controlling person" approach to DeFi, under which regulation should depend on who effectively controls a financial service. CryptoUK's argument is that if control is the test, then technical contributions and governance votes, absent that control, should not be enough to bring someone within the regime.
The phrase "by themselves" carries the weight of the request. CryptoUK is not asking for a blanket exemption for anyone connected to a protocol. It is asking the FCA to confirm that these activities alone do not amount to carrying on a regulated business, leaving the question of control to be assessed separately.
4. Where the draft is said to exceed the legislation
Support for the draft came with a list of provisions the group welcomed. CryptoUK endorsed the exclusions the guidance sets out for temporary settlement and payment arrangements, for assets backing UK-recognized stablecoins, for proprietary trading and market making, and for technical service providers.
Its criticism is that in certain places the draft "goes further than the legislation." The response identified three areas. The first is a proposed UK link based on where a protocol is developed or governed, a test that could bring an activity into scope because of the location of the people working on it. The second is a set of requirements attached to the exclusions for payments and for proprietary trading. The third is a group of indicators that, in the association's reading, would narrow the exclusion for technical services.
The common thread is a concern that guidance could tighten the regime beyond what was legislated. An exclusion written into legislation has a defined scope. If guidance adds conditions before a firm can rely on it, or lists indicators that take firms out of it, the practical reach of the exclusion shrinks even though the legal text is unchanged. CryptoUK's position, reflected in its call for guidance that tracks the legislation, is that the manual should explain the perimeter set by lawmakers and not redraw it.
The development-and-governance link connects directly to the DeFi point. A test tied to where a protocol is built or governed would bear most heavily on UK-based developers and governance participants, the same people the association wants the FCA to confirm are not regulated simply because of that work.
5. The FCA's acknowledgment on timing
The regulator has itself recognized that the sequence of events caused difficulty. The FCA acknowledged that the timing of the latest amendments created uncertainty for firms.
It also offered a practical remedy for those affected. The FCA said it will give extra time to applicants whose authorization was held up by questions about the technical services exclusion. That exclusion matters to companies that supply software or infrastructure to others without themselves providing the financial service, and uncertainty over its scope can leave such a company unsure whether it needs to apply at all.
For those applicants, the final guidance due in January 2027 should settle the question that delayed them. Until then, the allowance of additional time means that firms caught by the ambiguity are not penalized for a delay that stemmed from the unsettled state of the rules.
6. Stablecoin register and other requests
Beyond DeFi, the response sets out several requests aimed at making the regime easier to navigate. CryptoUK asked the FCA to publish a public record of the stablecoins that qualify under the UK regime. Such a register would let firms and users check whether a particular token has recognized status without having to work it out from the legal definitions.
The association also asked the regulator to clarify how stablecoins differ from electronic money. Both involve value that is issued against funds and used for payments, and the two are treated under separate sets of rules, so a clear boundary determines which requirements an issuer or service provider must meet.
A third request was for more worked examples of activities that fall outside the perimeter. Examples are a standard feature of perimeter guidance, because they show how abstract definitions apply to concrete business models. Additional cases on the excluded side of the line would give companies more reference points when assessing their own position.
7. Competitiveness and alignment with the EU
Some of the group's concerns lie outside what the FCA can fix through guidance alone, because they arise from the legislation. On those, CryptoUK urged the regulator to raise with the Treasury the outcomes that put UK firms at a disadvantage.
It gave two examples. One is the treatment of UK technical providers that offer access to regulated trading venues overseas. The other is the treatment of payments made with stablecoins issued abroad. In both cases, the association's concern is the effect of the rules on businesses based in the UK.
The response further said the UK should align with the European Union's Markets in Crypto-Assets framework, known as MiCA, "where appropriate." MiCA is the EU's rulebook for crypto, and many firms that operate in the UK also serve customers in the bloc. Alignment where the two regimes address the same issue would reduce the need to meet two different sets of requirements.
The submission was prepared with the law firm CMS and signed by Nick Brooks, CryptoUK's policy director.
8. What comes next for the UK regime
The perimeter consultation is one part of a larger program of work on the FCA's crypto rulebook. The regulator finalized its core crypto rules in June, ahead of a regime that is due to take effect on October 25, 2027. It later issued guidance two weeks before its crypto authorization window opened, and it has set out a shared vision for tokenization with the Bank of England.
The next fixed point is January 2027, when the FCA aims to publish the final perimeter guidance. That document will show whether the regulator has adopted CryptoUK's wording on software development and decentralized governance, whether it has kept or revised the proposed UK link based on where a protocol is developed or governed, and how it has handled the conditions and indicators the association said exceed the legislation.
After that, attention turns to the start date of October 25, 2027. Firms that need authorization must secure it under the new framework, and those relying on an exclusion will need to be confident that it applies to them. The final shape of the perimeter guidance will determine how many companies and individuals in the UK's crypto sector fall into each group.
