Analysis•

S&P Holds Tether's USDT at Its Lowest Stability Score as Riskier Reserves Reach 28%, and Tether Answers by Citing The Big Short

S&P Global Ratings left USDT at 5, its weakest stability score, on November 18 as higher-risk reserve assets rose to 28%. Tether blamed the agency's framework.

Written By :MINRK
S&P Holds Tether's USDT at Its Lowest Stability Score as Riskier Reserves Reach 28%, and Tether Answers by Citing The Big Short

Photo by rc.xyz NFT gallery on Unsplash

Mentioned in This Article

USDT
USDT
Tether
$1.00
0.01%
BTC
BTC
Bitcoin
$59,027.00
2.12%

1. Tether S&P Rating Stays at the Bottom of the Scale

S&P Global Ratings kept Tether's USDT (USDT) at the lowest point on its stablecoin stability scale in a report published on November 18, 2026. The Tether S&P rating remains 5, labeled 'weak', the same score assigned in November 2025, as higher-risk assets grew to 28% of the tokens in circulation.

The score measures a stablecoin's ability to hold its peg to the US dollar. The agency's scale runs from 1 at the strong end to 5 at the weak end, and USDT has now occupied the final rung for a full year.

An unchanged score did not mean an unchanged view. S&P said it had identified further weaknesses since its previous review, but it could make no downward adjustment because the assessment cannot go lower than 5. The stability score stayed where it was because there was nowhere further for it to fall.

The assessment carries weight because of what the token is used for. A dollar-pegged stablecoin serves as the cash leg of crypto trading and as a means of moving value between exchanges, wallets and countries without touching a bank account. Holders treat each unit as interchangeable with one dollar, and that assumption rests on the issuer holding enough sound assets to redeem tokens on demand. An evaluation of how reliably an issuer can do so is, in effect, an evaluation of whether that assumption would survive a period of market stress.

Tether rejected the conclusion. The company said the problem lies with S&P's framework and not with the assets that back its token, and it reached for a cultural reference to make the point, invoking The Big Short, the film about the 2008 financial crisis, to suggest that the agency's own history exposes the flaw in its approach.

2. Why Did S&P Rate Tether as Weak?

S&P's central concern is the composition of the reserves that stand behind USDT. The agency grouped five types of holdings as higher-risk assets: gold, Bitcoin (BTC), public equities, secured loans and corporate bonds.

As of September 30, those holdings were equivalent to 28% of USDT in circulation. A year earlier the figure was 24%. The direction of travel matters as much as the level, because it shows the reserve mix moving further from the cash-like instruments that rating agencies regard as the safest backing for a token that promises to be redeemable at one dollar.

The risk S&P describes is straightforward. A stablecoin is fully backed only as long as the market value of its reserves matches or exceeds the value of the tokens outstanding. Assets such as Bitcoin, gold and listed shares can lose value quickly. S&P warned that a significant drop in the value of these holdings could leave USDT undercollateralized, meaning the reserves would be worth less than the tokens they are supposed to support.

Short-dated government debt does not carry that risk to the same degree, which is why the proportion of a reserve held in volatile or less liquid assets is a core input into assessments of this kind.

3. The Reserve Figures Tether Points To

Tether's own numbers show a cushion above its liabilities. The company's reserve report for September 30, attested by the accounting firm BDO, listed approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities.

That leaves roughly $7.95 billion in excess reserves. The surplus is the buffer that would absorb losses on the reserve portfolio before the token's backing fell below the value of USDT in circulation.

The disagreement between the company and the agency is therefore not about whether the reserves currently exceed the liabilities. It is about how much stress the portfolio could withstand. S&P's analysis weighs the size of the buffer against the share of reserves held in assets whose prices can swing sharply. Tether's position is that the framework used to make that judgment is the thing at fault.

4. El Salvador's Rules and the Question of Segregation

Regulation forms the second strand of the agency's critique. Tether relocated to El Salvador in January 2025, where its regulator is the National Commission of Digital Assets, known by its Spanish initials CNAD.

CNAD requires that 70% of reserves be held in assets that can be sold within 30 days. S&P nonetheless described the broader framework as permissive, because it allows reserves to include gold, Bitcoin and loans, the same categories the agency counts as higher risk.

S&P also drew attention to how reserve assets are held. El Salvador does not require them to be segregated, in contrast to the approach taken by regulators in the United States and Europe. Segregation means keeping the assets that back a stablecoin legally and operationally separate from the issuer's other property, so that they remain available to token holders if the company itself runs into trouble.

No public information is available on whether Tether's reserves are segregated. Without it, S&P said, it cannot determine whether the reserves are protected from corporate risks. For holders, that leaves open the question of what claim they would have on the backing assets if the issuer faced financial distress unrelated to the reserves themselves.

5. An Audit Completed but Not Published

Disclosure is the third area where S&P found shortcomings, despite a milestone the company reached this year. In August 2026, KPMG issued an unqualified opinion on Tether's 2025 accounts, described as the company's first full independent audit. Tether said the audit supported its published financial statements.

An unqualified opinion is the clean result an auditor gives when it concludes that financial statements present a fair picture. For a company that had long faced criticism for relying on attestations instead of a full audit, it was a significant step.

S&P's objection is that outsiders cannot examine the result. The audited financial statements and the auditor's report have not been published, the agency said, which limits how far the findings can be verified.

The agency listed other gaps as well. Tether's reserve reports do not name the custodians that hold the assets or the counterparties involved. Its attestations are issued quarterly, whereas other stablecoins generally report monthly. Less frequent reporting means a longer interval in which the composition of the reserves can change without the market being informed.

6. Tether's Response and Its History With the Agency

Tether has contested S&P's reading from the start. When the agency first downgraded USDT in 2025, the company disputed the result, and Chief Executive Paolo Ardoino took to X to cite past financial collapses as evidence that traditional systems are broken.

The reference to The Big Short continues that line of argument. The film dramatizes the period before the 2008 crisis, when mortgage-linked securities that carried high ratings turned out to be far riskier than their grades implied. By raising it, Tether is suggesting that an institution whose assessments failed then is poorly placed to judge the soundness of its reserves now.

Neither side has shifted in the year since. S&P has repeated its score and added to its list of concerns, while Tether has repeated its objection to the method. The company's answer this time did not dispute the individual figures in the report, such as the 28% share of higher-risk holdings. It challenged the premise that those figures should be read the way the agency reads them.

The exchange illustrates a wider divide. S&P applies criteria rooted in conventional credit analysis, in which liquid, low-volatility assets, strong regulation, segregation and frequent public disclosure all count toward a higher score. Tether argues that those criteria do not capture how its business operates, and it points to its reserve surplus and its completed audit as evidence of strength.

7. A Peg That Has Held

One finding in the report favors the company. Even while leaving the score at the bottom of its scale, S&P said Tether has maintained a good record of price stability, particularly over the last 12 months.

That distinction is important for reading the assessment correctly. The score is a judgment about the capacity of a stablecoin to keep its peg under stress, based on what backs it and how it is governed and supervised. It is not a statement that the peg has broken or that redemptions have failed. USDT has continued to trade close to one dollar through the period in which it has carried the weakest score.

S&P's assessment and USDT's market record therefore describe different things. One looks at structural safeguards and what could happen if reserve assets lost value sharply. The other reflects what has happened in practice over the past year.

8. What Would Change the Picture

The report makes clear which factors are holding the score down, and each of them is something that can be measured in future reviews. The first is the share of higher-risk assets, which stood at 28% of USDT in circulation on September 30 after rising from 24% a year before. Tether's next quarterly reserve attestation will show whether that proportion has continued to climb.

The second is disclosure. Publication of the KPMG-audited statements and the auditor's report would address one of the gaps S&P identified, as would naming custodians and counterparties or moving to more frequent reporting.

The third is the protection of reserves. Public information on whether the assets are segregated from the company's other holdings would let the agency assess whether they are shielded from corporate risks. Until those points change, S&P's position is that USDT sits at the weakest score it is able to assign, with additional weaknesses that the scale has no room to reflect.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY