Analysis•

Prediction Markets Matched the Polls in Most Midterm Races, and Missed the Same Senate Upsets

Kalshi and Polymarket largely agreed with polling in key 2026 midterm races, but both tools missed upsets in Iowa, Mississippi and South Carolina where data was thin.

Written By :MINRK
Prediction Markets Matched the Polls in Most Midterm Races, and Missed the Same Senate Upsets

Photo by Bozhin Karaivanov on Unsplash

1. Prediction markets midterms record: mostly aligned with polls

Prediction markets and traditional polling largely agreed on the outcome of the key 2026 U.S. midterm races. In the days after the vote, a review of the closely watched contests found that both tools pointed to the eventual winner in most of them. Both also missed the same handful of upsets, including Senate seats in Iowa, Mississippi and South Carolina.

The comparison matters because the midterms were the first national election since platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket grew from niche experiments into heavily traded venues. The election produced a so-called blue wave, with Democrats picking up seats in places where few forecasters expected them to compete. That gave observers a clear test of whether betting on outcomes reveals anything the polls do not.

The short answer from this cycle is mixed. Where polls were plentiful, the markets tended to track them closely. Where polls were scarce or absent, the markets had little to anchor them, and several of their confident calls turned out to be wrong.

2. A debate that began in 2020

The question of whether prediction markets beat polls is not new. It has circulated for at least six years, going back to the 2020 presidential race, when early event-contract platforms were small and lightly used and analysts compared their prices with polling averages mainly out of curiosity.

The mechanics are simple. A typical election contract pays a fixed amount, usually one dollar, if a stated outcome occurs and nothing if it does not. Its trading price therefore works as an implied probability: a contract trading at 70 cents suggests traders collectively see about a 70% chance of that result. Prices shift as people buy and sell, which is why supporters describe the markets as a running, real-time forecast.

Since then the platforms have carved out a lasting place in political coverage. Contract prices are now quoted alongside polling averages on election night, and traders, campaign staff and journalists all watch them. What remains unsettled is the nature of that place. One view holds that the markets mainly serve speculators who want exposure to political events. Another holds that the money at stake forces traders to process information efficiently, which would make the prices a genuine forecasting tool.

After the midterm results came in, the argument resurfaced on X, the social platform formerly known as Twitter. Supporters of the markets pointed to races where contract prices moved early. Skeptics pointed to races where the markets were confidently wrong. Each side found examples to support its case.

3. Do prediction markets follow the polls or lead them?

Neither the polls nor the markets can settle this on their own, and that is the core difficulty with judging the platforms. If a contract price simply mirrors the latest polling average, the market adds little that a reader could not get from the polls directly. If prices move before the polls do, the market may be capturing information that surveys have not yet picked up.

This chicken-or-egg problem is hard to untangle after the fact. Traders read polls, so some overlap is expected. A price that matches a poll on the eve of an election does not show whether traders were following the survey or had reached the same conclusion on their own.

One useful way to read the markets is to treat them as a gauge of confidence rather than a stand-in for public opinion. A poll asks voters what they intend to do. A contract price shows how strongly traders, with money at risk, believe a particular result will happen. Those are related but different measurements. A race can poll as a dead heat while the market prices one candidate as a clear favorite, because traders are weighing turnout, past polling errors, fundraising or the partisan lean of a district.

Read that way, the markets become one input among several rather than a replacement for surveys, fundamentals-based models or local reporting. That framing is helpful, but it still does not answer the underlying question of whether the confidence the markets express is well founded.

4. Three races where both tools stumbled

In the main contests under review, markets and polls generally agreed with each other and with the final results. The exceptions were telling, because in each case the two tools erred together or the markets went further than the polls justified.

In Wisconsin's 1st Congressional District, Republican Rep. Bryan Steil lost his seat to Democrat Mitchell Berman. On the Friday before Election Day, both the polls and the markets showed the race as essentially tied. Neither signaled that Berman would win, though neither ruled it out.

Alabama's 2nd Congressional District went the other way. Rep. Shomari Figures held the seat against challenger Rhett Marques, even though both the polls and the prediction markets had shown Marques ahead in the newly redrawn district. A redrawn map makes forecasting harder, because past results are a weaker guide when the boundaries and the mix of voters change, and in this case both methods overestimated the challenger.

The Iowa Senate race was the clearest split between the two. State Rep. Josh Turek defeated Rep. Ashley Hinson, flipping the seat to the Democrats. The markets had favored Hinson, while the polling averages showed a race close to 50/50. Here the polls came nearer to capturing the true uncertainty, and the traders' extra confidence in Hinson proved misplaced.

5. Upsets in races with little polling or market coverage

Outside the most heavily watched contests, the picture was murkier. Several races drew few polls and few or no market contracts, which left voters, campaigns and traders with little to go on.

Mississippi's Senate race was one of the biggest surprises of the night. Polymarket's contract favored incumbent Republican Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith right up until returns began arriving on Tuesday night. Kalshi did not list a contract on the race at all. Democrat Scott Colom won the seat.

South Carolina produced another upset. Neither Polymarket nor Kalshi offered a stand-alone contract on the Senate race there. Polymarket did list a parlay, a single contract that pays out only if a bettor correctly picks the winners of several races, in this case the Senate contests in Montana, South Carolina and Mississippi. Democrat Annie Andrews won the South Carolina seat. Neither company responded to questions about its coverage of these races.

Polling was also thin in both states. A widely used public archive of election surveys showed Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham ahead by a single point in the most recent South Carolina poll, and it held no polls at all for Mississippi. Other sites cited surveys that showed Hyde-Smith narrowly ahead.

6. Why sparse data makes prediction markets hard to judge

These low-information races expose the limits of any scorecard for the platforms. When a contest is barely polled, traders have little public data to work with, and contract prices can reflect assumptions about a state's partisan lean more than any fresh evidence. A market that favors the incumbent in a state that usually votes Republican may simply be restating that history.

Judging the markets fairly in these cases is difficult. If a race appears to flip unexpectedly and almost nobody was measuring it, it is not obvious whether the markets failed or whether the information needed to foresee the result did not exist. Polls face the same problem. A single survey showing a one-point lead is a fragile basis for any prediction, and the absence of polling leaves forecasters guessing.

The midterm results suggest that the markets are at their most convincing when there is plenty of information for traders to process, and at their weakest exactly where an independent signal would be most valuable. That is an uncomfortable finding for anyone hoping the platforms could fill the gaps left by declining public polling. The question of how to evaluate them in thinly covered races remains open.

7. What the results mean for the prediction market industry

For the platforms, the midterms were both a showcase and a stress test. Election contracts are among their most visible products, and their performance shapes how the public and policymakers view the sector as a whole. A cycle in which the markets largely matched the polls in major races helps their case that they are serious tools rather than novelties.

The misses in Iowa, Mississippi and South Carolina complicate that story. Critics can argue that traders mostly borrowed their confidence from polls and partisan history, adding little independent insight. Supporters can respond that the markets were no worse than the surveys and that a handful of upsets in a wave election is expected from any forecasting method.

For readers, the practical lesson is to treat contract prices as one measure among several. A market price is a statement of collective confidence backed by money, not a guarantee. It is most useful alongside polling averages, structural models and on-the-ground reporting, and least reliable when those other sources are silent.

8. What's next: SEC nominees head to the Senate Banking Committee

Attention in Washington now shifts from the election results to the confirmation process. On Thursday, November 19, at 10 a.m. Eastern time (15:00 UTC), the Senate Banking Committee is scheduled to hold a nomination hearing covering several candidates, including President Donald Trump's nominees for the Securities and Exchange Commission.

The SEC oversees securities markets and has a central role in how digital assets are classified and regulated in the United States, so the hearing will be closely watched by the crypto industry. The debate over how to measure the value of prediction markets will continue well beyond this cycle, and the next major election will offer another chance to test whether traders can see what the polls miss.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY