Regulation•

Oversight Committee Staff Ask Congress to Weigh Barring Lawmakers and Federal Officials From Prediction Markets

A House Oversight staff memo released November 13 urges Congress to consider limiting or fully banning prediction market trading by lawmakers, their staff and federal officials.

Written By :MINRK
Oversight Committee Staff Ask Congress to Weigh Barring Lawmakers and Federal Officials From Prediction Markets

Photo by Darren Irvin on Unsplash

1. A prediction market ban for Washington goes on the table

Staff on the House Oversight Committee have asked Congress to consider a prediction market ban covering members of Congress, congressional staff and federal officials, in a memo released November 13. The document lays out two paths: a full prohibition on trading, or narrower limits that would at minimum cover contracts tied to government actions and political outcomes.

The recommendation goes further than existing insider trading rules. Committee staff argue that restrictions on politically sensitive contracts should apply to officials whether or not they are trading on inside information. In their view, the mere possibility that someone in government could profit from what they learn on the job is enough to justify keeping them out of certain markets altogether.

The memo is not legislation. It contains no bill text, and it is not an adopted committee report. Any new rules would require Congress to draft, debate and pass a law, and the staff document simply asks lawmakers to consider doing so.

2. What the Oversight memo recommends

The core request is that Congress weigh limits on prediction market activity by officials in every branch of the federal government. Staff left the precise scope open. One option is an outright prohibition on participation in prediction markets. The other is a targeted restriction on a subset of contracts, such as those connected to government decisions or the results of political contests.

Whichever route is chosen, the memo frames the goal in terms of public confidence. Applying the limits across all branches, staff wrote, would eliminate even the appearance that officials are cashing in on nonpublic information they obtained through their work. That standard, focused on appearance rather than proof of misuse, is what separates the proposal from the case-by-case approach of current insider trading enforcement.

Staff also stressed that, at a minimum, the restrictions should reach contracts on government actions and political outcomes regardless of whether the trader holds insider knowledge. Those are the markets where officials are most likely to have an informational edge, or to be perceived as having one, simply because of the positions they hold.

3. Who wrote it and how it fits into the committee's work

The document was prepared by committee staff for the panel's majority members. The House Oversight Committee is chaired by Representative James Comer, a Kentucky Republican. Staff framed their conclusions as a request for Congress to consider legislation rather than as a formal position of the committee.

The memo is the product of an investigation that began in May, when the committee sent letters to Kalshi and Polymarket, the two most prominent prediction market operators in the United States. The inquiry later widened to include Hyperliquid Labs, Crypto.com and PredictIt. Over the course of the probe, the committee gathered nearly 1,700 pages of records from the companies involved.

Sam Enzer, a partner at the law firm Cahill Gordon & Reindel, said in June, shortly after the investigation started, that a Republican chairman opening an inquiry into the platforms was a clear signal of enormous pressure on legislators to establish clear rules for the sector. Enzer also warned that if adversaries could pick up advance signals about US military operations from prediction market activity, that would pose a threat to national security.

4. Does insider trading law already cover event contracts?

Yes, according to the committee staff. They concluded that existing federal law already applies to event contracts, the yes-or-no instruments that prediction markets list on questions ranging from elections to economic data releases. A trader who uses confidential information to buy a contract on an outcome they have privileged knowledge of can already be held to account.

The memo points to two statutes. The first is the Commodity Exchange Act, the law that governs futures and other derivatives markets in the United States. The second is the Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act, better known as the STOCK Act, which bars lawmakers and federal employees from trading on nonpublic information they gain through their official duties.

The proposed limits would go a step further. Instead of relying on after-the-fact enforcement against people who misuse information, they would close some markets to officials entirely. That shift from policing conduct to restricting access is the main change the memo asks Congress to consider.

5. Why contracts on government actions draw the most concern

Prediction markets let users buy and sell contracts that pay out depending on whether a specific event happens. A contract on an election, a regulatory decision or a policy announcement trades at a price that reflects how likely participants think the outcome is, and that price moves as new information arrives. Traders who learn something before everyone else can profit by buying or selling ahead of the crowd.

That structure is what makes contracts tied to government decisions so sensitive. The people who draft legislation, schedule votes, prepare enforcement actions or plan military operations know about those events before the public does. If they, or their staff, can trade on the outcomes, the line between public service and private gain becomes difficult to police, even when no one can prove that a particular trade relied on confidential knowledge.

Insider trading enforcement typically requires investigators to show that a trader possessed material nonpublic information and acted on it. Building such a case can take months or years, and many suspicious trades never lead to charges. A rule that simply keeps officials out of certain markets avoids that evidentiary burden, which is why the committee staff framed their proposal around removing even the appearance of improper profit.

The same reasoning explains why the memo singles out political outcomes. Officials and campaign staff often have access to internal polling, strategy discussions and private conversations that ordinary traders lack. Allowing them to wager on races in which they have a stake, or on the timing of decisions they help shape, would invite the kind of public suspicion the staff memo is trying to prevent.

6. Restrictions already in place in the Senate and the Pentagon

Parts of the federal government have already moved on their own. In April, the Senate passed a resolution that bars senators and their staff from using prediction markets. That measure applies only to the Senate, which is part of why the House staff memo calls for rules that would cover officials across all branches.

The Defense Department has also acted. It recently prohibited service members and civilian personnel from using material nonpublic information or prediction platforms for personal financial gain. Given the sensitivity of military planning, the department's move reflects the same concern Enzer raised about the national security risks of prediction market activity.

Taken together, these steps show a patchwork of rules emerging institution by institution. The Oversight staff memo is an attempt to push Congress toward a single, consistent standard rather than leaving each chamber and agency to write its own.

7. The Maduro raid case and other examples in the memo

The memo draws on several cases to illustrate the risks. The most striking involves an indictment alleging that Army Master Sergeant Gannon Ken Van Dyke used classified information about the operation that captured Venezuelan leader Nicolas Maduro to make more than $409,000 on Polymarket.

If proven, the case would represent exactly the kind of abuse that worries national security officials: a person with access to secret operational details turning that knowledge into trading profits on a public platform. It also demonstrates that prediction market prices can, in principle, move in ways that reveal sensitive information to anyone watching.

Staff also listed orders from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the federal derivatives regulator, against former Representative George Santos and against Gabriel Perez, a White House teleprompter operator. According to the memo, Kalshi flagged both of those cases to authorities.

8. Platforms credited with catching most cases

One notable feature of the memo is the credit it gives the platforms themselves. Committee staff found that most of the reported cases of suspected misuse were first detected by the prediction market operators, rather than by regulators or law enforcement.

That finding shapes one of the memo's practical recommendations. Staff asked Congress to make sure that platforms and regulators share the information needed to enforce any new limits. A ban on trading by officials would only be effective if someone can identify when a covered person opens an account or places a trade, and the platforms are best positioned to see that activity.

The emphasis on cooperation suggests that staff see the operators as partners in enforcement rather than purely as targets of oversight, even as the committee's investigation continues to examine their practices.

9. What happens next

The next step belongs to Congress. Because the memo contains no bill text and has not been adopted as a committee report, it carries no legal force. Lawmakers would need to introduce legislation, decide between a full prohibition and narrower limits on government-related contracts, and settle how far the rules should reach across the executive, legislative and judicial branches.

The memo also leaves the design of any information-sharing system between platforms and regulators to legislators. Those details will matter if Congress takes up the recommendations, since enforcement depends on regulators knowing who is trading and on what.

In the meantime, the Senate's April resolution and the Defense Department's recent restrictions remain the most concrete limits on officials' participation in prediction markets, and the existing insider trading statutes continue to apply to anyone in government who trades on nonpublic information.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY