Crime•

A German Judge Offers to Drop the Movie2K Case for 40,000 Bitcoin, Leaving the Defendant With About $1 Billion

A Leipzig judge has proposed ending the Movie2K trial if the main defendant surrenders 40,000 Bitcoin and pays €38 million. Prosecutors believe he would still hold about 16,000 coins.

Written By :MINRK
A German Judge Offers to Drop the Movie2K Case for 40,000 Bitcoin, Leaving the Defendant With About $1 Billion

Photo by Kanchanara on Unsplash

Mentioned in This Article

BTC
BTC
Bitcoin
$59,027.00
2.12%

1. The Movie2K Bitcoin Offer in Brief

The presiding judge at the Leipzig Regional Court in Germany has proposed dropping tax evasion and money laundering charges against the 43-year-old alleged operator of the defunct film piracy site Movie2K if he surrenders 40,000 Bitcoin (BTC) and pays €38 million ($42 million) in compensation. The proposal emerged last week, and the trial resumes on December 3, 2026.

Saxony's Office of the Public Prosecutor General has confirmed that the offer was made. The Movie2K Bitcoin proposal stands out because of what it would leave behind. Prosecutors believe the main defendant controls roughly 56,000 BTC in total, which means that accepting the terms would still leave him with around 16,000 coins. At the time of writing, that remainder is worth approximately €940 million, or about $1 billion.

In other words, a man accused of running one of the most widely used piracy portals of its era could walk out of a German courtroom with the criminal case closed and a fortune that still sits near the billion-dollar mark. No agreement has been reached. His defense team is still considering the proposal, and the court has not yet ruled on anything.

2. What the Judge Put on the Table

Two components make up the proposal aimed at the main defendant. The first is the transfer of 40,000 BTC to the authorities. At current prices, that quantity of Bitcoin is valued at roughly €2.36 billion, or about $2.6 billion. The second is a cash payment of €38 million, equivalent to about $42 million, which is intended as compensation for potential victims.

Taken together, the two components are heavily weighted toward the cryptocurrency. The cash element amounts to less than 2% of the value of the coins at today's prices, so the Bitcoin transfer is, in practical terms, the settlement. The compensation payment serves a different purpose: it creates a pool of conventional money that can be directed to those who may have been harmed, without anyone having to wait for digital assets to be sold.

In exchange, the court would discontinue the proceedings on the two categories of charges that remain live in the case: tax evasion and money laundering. A discontinuation of this kind ends a prosecution without a verdict, so the defendant would be neither convicted nor acquitted on those counts.

The value of what he would keep has already shifted with the market. The roughly 16,000 BTC that would remain in his hands was worth more than €1 billion on the day the offer was made. Bitcoin's price has slipped since then, bringing the figure down to approximately €940 million. Because the proposal is denominated in coins rather than euros, the state's share and the defendant's share both rise and fall with the market until any transfer actually takes place.

3. A Separate Deal for the Co-Defendant

A second man is standing trial alongside the alleged operator, and the court has put a different, far smaller proposal to him. Under its terms, the co-defendant would hand over 600 BTC and pay €17 million, or about $19 million.

His lawyer has indicated that this offer is one her client could accept. The position of the main defendant is less settled. His lawyers are still weighing the terms presented to him and have not said publicly which way they are leaning.

The calendar leaves limited room for deliberation. Hearings are scheduled to resume on December 3, and the proceedings could be wrapped up before Christmas. If both defendants agree to the court's terms, a case that has been running since February could end within weeks, without the court ever having to rule on the hardest evidentiary questions.

4. Why Would the Court Drop the Charges?

The short answer is that parts of the case appear difficult to prove. The judge has reportedly expressed doubt that some of the charges can be established in court, and one reason is that Bitcoin acquired lawfully and Bitcoin acquired unlawfully may be mixed together in the defendant's accounts.

That mixing problem goes to the core of a money laundering prosecution. To secure a conviction, prosecutors generally have to show that specific assets stem from a criminal offense. When coins from different origins have been pooled over many years, drawing a clean line between tainted and untainted holdings becomes a demanding exercise, even though every Bitcoin transaction is recorded on a public ledger.

There is a second structural weakness in the case. The offenses most directly associated with a piracy site, the copyright violations themselves, can no longer be prosecuted because the statute of limitations has expired. Movie2K went offline in 2013, more than a decade before the trial opened. With the copyright counts time-barred, the proceedings that began in February have centered entirely on money laundering and tax evasion.

Seen against those obstacles, a negotiated end offers the state a certain outcome in place of an uncertain one. A settlement would deliver 40,000 BTC and a compensation fund without the risk that a contested verdict yields less, or is overturned later.

5. How a Piracy Site Produced a Bitcoin Fortune

Movie2K was, in its day, a large-scale source of unlicensed films. Before it shut down in 2013, the site offered access to hundreds of thousands of pirated titles. Its operators did not charge for the films in a conventional way. Instead, the money came from advertising and from so-called subscription traps, arrangements that draw users into recurring payments they did not clearly agree to.

The proceeds were then put heavily into Bitcoin at a time when the cryptocurrency traded at a small fraction of its present value. That timing explains the scale of the sums now being discussed in Leipzig. Income from a website that closed in 2013 would not, on its own, amount to billions of euros. The appreciation of Bitcoin over the following years is what turned those earnings into one of the largest cryptocurrency holdings ever linked to a criminal case.

It is also what makes the proposed settlement so unusual in its arithmetic. The state would collect 40,000 BTC, an enormous recovery by any standard, and the defendant would still be left with a ten-figure sum.

6. The 50,000 Bitcoin Saxony Already Sold

This is not the first time coins tied to Movie2K have passed to the German state. The main defendant was arrested abroad in 2023, and in early 2024 he handed over nearly 50,000 BTC to the authorities.

Saxony sold that entire stock later in 2024, raising about €2.64 billion, or roughly $2.9 billion. The money has not been absorbed into the public budget. It is held in an account of the state judicial treasury, and legally it still belongs to the defendant until a final ruling determines what happens to it.

That detail matters for the settlement talks. The earlier handover was a provisional step taken during the investigation, not a penalty imposed by a court, and the fate of the proceeds depends on how the criminal case ends. A discontinuation in exchange for 40,000 BTC would therefore sit alongside an unresolved question about a sum of euros that is larger than the value of the coins now being requested.

The sale also reshaped Germany's standing as a holder of digital assets. Once the coins were gone, the German government was left with less than $300 million in Bitcoin.

Not everyone accepts that the 2024 handover covered everything connected to the site. The blockchain analytics firm Arkham said last year that German authorities had failed to seize about 45,000 BTC linked to Movie2K. Prosecutors' present estimate that the defendant holds about 56,000 BTC shows that investigators now also believe a very large balance stayed outside the state's reach after the first transfer.

7. New German Powers to Seize Crypto of Doubtful Origin

The judge's proposal arrives at a moment when Germany is tightening its approach to unexplained wealth. Only days before the offer became public, German lawmakers approved new powers that allow customs officials to seize assets, including cryptocurrency whose origin is in doubt, without first opening a criminal case.

The law changes who carries the burden of explanation. Owners of significant assets would be required to demonstrate that what they hold was obtained lawfully, rather than the state having to prove that it was not.

The contrast with the Leipzig trial is instructive. In a criminal prosecution, the difficulty of separating legal from illegal coins works in the defendant's favor, because doubt benefits the accused. Under a regime in which the owner must account for the source of the assets, the same uncertainty would cut the other way. The Movie2K proceedings are being conducted under the criminal rules, which is one reason a settlement that leaves the defendant with about 16,000 BTC is on the table at all.

8. What Happens Next

The next fixed date is December 3, when the trial resumes at the Leipzig Regional Court. By then, the main defendant's lawyers will have had several weeks to decide whether to accept the transfer of 40,000 BTC and the €38 million payment in return for an end to the proceedings.

If they agree, and the co-defendant accepts his own terms of 600 BTC and €17 million, the case could conclude before Christmas. The outcome would also bear on the roughly €2.64 billion from the 2024 sale, which remains in the judicial treasury account pending a final ruling.

If the defense declines, the trial continues on the money laundering and tax evasion charges, and prosecutors would have to overcome the evidentiary problems the judge has already flagged. Either way, the closing weeks of 2026 are likely to determine how much of a fortune built on a long-defunct piracy site ends up with the state of Saxony, and how much stays with the man accused of running it.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY