Regulation•

Commerce Published the Chinese AI Chip Access Rule, but Treasury and the NSC Wrote It Over Lutnick's Head

A US rule limiting Chinese firms' use of American AI chips in overseas data centers was drafted at the direction of Treasury and the National Security Council, not Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick.

Written By :MINRK
Commerce Published the Chinese AI Chip Access Rule, but Treasury and the NSC Wrote It Over Lutnick's Head

Photo by Jason Leung on Unsplash

1. Treasury and the Security Council Take Over a Commerce Rule

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and the White House National Security Council (NSC) went around Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to push through a rule, issued on November 16, 2026, that limits Chinese companies' access to American artificial intelligence chips housed in overseas data centers. The Lutnick Bessent split is now on the public record: the Commerce bureau that released the rule says it was drafted under Treasury and NSC direction.

That acknowledgment came from the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS), the arm of the Commerce Department that administers US export controls. BIS normally writes such measures itself and answers to the commerce secretary. In this case the bureau confirmed that the drafting was steered from outside the department, by Treasury and by the president's national security staff.

President Donald Trump has nonetheless said he retains confidence in Lutnick. According to the president, a disagreement between agencies over the pace and shape of export policy does not mean the commerce secretary is being pushed out or stripped of his authority. The episode still leaves an unusual picture: a rule carrying the Commerce Department's name that the department's own leadership did not originate.

2. What does the new AI chip rule restrict?

The rule restricts Chinese companies from tapping US AI-chip computing power through data centers located outside China. It is aimed at access to the processing capacity itself, rather than only at the physical shipment of semiconductors into the country.

The distinction matters because of how advanced computing is bought and sold. Training and running large AI models requires clusters of specialized processors, the most capable of which are designed by American companies. A firm that wants that capacity has two broad options. It can buy the chips and install them in its own facilities, or it can rent time on chips that someone else owns and operates, connecting to them over the internet in the same way any business uses cloud services.

Existing US export controls were written mainly around the first option. They limit which processors may be sold and shipped to China. They are less well suited to the second, in which the hardware legally sits in a third country and never crosses the Chinese border, while the work it performs is done on behalf of a Chinese customer. A rule focused on overseas data centers is an attempt to address that second route, so that restrictions on selling chips to a company cannot be sidestepped by leasing the same computing power abroad.

3. Why the Lutnick Bessent split matters

Export controls on semiconductors sit at the intersection of trade policy and national security, and the two goals do not always point the same way. The Commerce Department is responsible both for promoting American industry abroad and for policing what that industry may sell. The Treasury Department manages sanctions and the financial side of economic statecraft, while the NSC coordinates security policy across the government on the president's behalf. Each institution brings a different instinct to the question of how hard to squeeze China's access to advanced technology.

When those instincts collide, the usual outcome is a negotiated text that the responsible agency then issues as its own. What sets this episode apart is that the responsible agency has said, in effect, that the text was not its own. By confirming that Treasury and the NSC directed the drafting, BIS made a private disagreement visible and attached names to each side of it: Bessent and the security council on one, Lutnick on the other.

The personalities involved add weight to the disagreement. Bessent, as treasury secretary, is the administration's senior economic official and a central figure in its dealings with Beijing. Lutnick runs the department that both licenses technology exports and champions American companies selling abroad. When two cabinet members of that rank end up on opposite sides of a rule, and the one with formal jurisdiction is the one who is overruled, the result is read as a statement about influence as much as about chips.

For companies that design, sell or rent AI hardware, the practical consequence is uncertainty about where decisions are made. Firms seeking licenses or guidance deal with BIS. If the substance of policy is being set elsewhere, the views of Treasury and the White House security staff become at least as important to anticipate as those of the commerce secretary.

4. How Export Rules Are Normally Written

Under ordinary procedure, BIS maintains the Export Administration Regulations, the rulebook that determines which American goods, software and technologies need a government license before they can go to particular destinations or end users. The bureau drafts changes, circulates them to other departments with a stake in the outcome, and publishes the final version. Other agencies comment and can object, but the pen stays with Commerce.

That arrangement gives the commerce secretary considerable influence over both the timing and the content of new controls. A secretary who prefers a narrower measure, or who wants to hold a rule back while trade negotiations are under way, has the procedural means to do so. It is that influence which the latest rule appears to have circumvented. Direction from Treasury and the NSC meant the measure advanced on their terms.

The bureau's decision to say so publicly is itself notable. Agencies rarely describe the internal authorship of their rules, and they almost never attribute one to other parts of the government. The statement reads as a deliberate marking of responsibility, and it has been widely taken as confirmation of friction inside the administration over how the United States should handle China's appetite for AI computing.

5. Trump Stands by His Commerce Secretary

The president's public position is that Lutnick stays. Trump has voiced confidence in the commerce secretary and has framed the dispute as a difference of opinion between departments, not a verdict on Lutnick's performance or a reallocation of his powers.

That framing leaves two things true at once. Lutnick keeps his post and his formal authority over BIS, and a significant rule within that authority was nevertheless shaped by others. How durable that arrangement proves is the open question. A cabinet officer can retain the president's backing while losing practical control of a policy area, and the reverse can also happen: a one-off intervention on a single rule may not be repeated.

Interagency disputes of this kind are a regular feature of export policy, and most never become public. Departments argue over drafts, the White House arbitrates, and the final rule appears without any record of who wanted what. The difference here is disclosure. Because BIS has attributed the drafting to Treasury and the NSC, the president was left to address a disagreement that would otherwise have stayed inside the government.

The president's remarks also matter for how the episode is read outside Washington. Speculation about Lutnick's position has followed the dispute, with the bypass interpreted by some observers as a sign that his standing is unstable. Trump's statement is the most direct evidence against that reading, and for now it is the administration's official line.

6. Why Remote Computing Became a Target

Advanced AI processors have become one of the most closely watched goods in US-China relations because they are the main constraint on how quickly powerful AI systems can be built. Washington has spent several years tightening the rules on which chips may be sold to Chinese buyers, on the reasoning that leadership in AI carries military and economic weight.

Rented computing complicates that strategy. Data centers in third countries can be stocked with American chips entirely within the law, then offer their capacity to customers anywhere. From the point of view of an AI developer, the location of the hardware is largely irrelevant; what counts is how much processing it can call on. A control regime that stops at the border therefore leaves a channel open for as long as overseas operators are free to serve Chinese clients.

Closing that channel has costs, which helps explain why agencies disagree about it. Restrictions on who may use a data center reach into the business of cloud providers and hardware suppliers, and they affect countries that host such facilities and are not themselves targets of US policy. Officials whose priority is security tend to see those costs as acceptable. Officials whose brief includes trade relationships and the commercial health of American chip companies tend to weigh them more heavily. The rule that emerged on November 16 reflects the first view prevailing.

7. What to Watch Next

Attention now turns to further statements about Lutnick, above all from Trump or Bessent. Either man could settle the question of the commerce secretary's standing with a sentence, in one direction or the other, and any comment from the White House on the matter will be read closely.

Cabinet changes would be the clearest signal that the dispute has had consequences beyond a single rule. Additional export-control measures would be another marker. If further restrictions follow and are again attributed to Treasury and the NSC, it would suggest a lasting shift in who steers this area of policy. If the next measures come through the ordinary Commerce process, the November rule may come to look like an exception.

Public criticism or support from influential policymakers could also move perceptions of where Lutnick stands. For the technology sector, the more immediate issue is the rule itself: who is covered, how access through overseas facilities will be policed, and how quickly operators and their customers must adjust. Those details will determine how much of the remote route to American AI computing remains open to Chinese companies.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY