Regulation•

Louisiana's Liz Murrill Brands CFTC Chair Michael Selig's Lawfare Charge "Flatly False" as Prediction Market Clash Escalates

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill rejected CFTC Chair Michael Selig's claims as "flatly false," arguing states have regulated gambling for 250 years as the federal lawsuit proceeds.

Written By :MINRK
Louisiana's Liz Murrill Brands CFTC Chair Michael Selig's Lawfare Charge "Flatly False" as Prediction Market Clash Escalates

Photo by The New York Public Library on Unsplash

1. Louisiana prediction markets fight turns personal

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill on November 14 rejected statements by Commodity Futures Trading Commission Chair Michael Selig as "flatly false," escalating the Louisiana prediction markets dispute after the CFTC and the Justice Department sued the state. Murrill argued that states have regulated gambling for 250 years and that a federal agency has no grounds to change that.

The exchange marks a sharp turn in a conflict that began as a legal disagreement over jurisdiction. It is now also a public clash between a state's top law enforcement officer and the head of the federal agency that oversees U.S. derivatives markets. In a post on X, Murrill described Selig as the "obsequious standard bearer" for Kalshi and the prediction market industry, a pointed suggestion that the regulator is acting as an advocate for the companies he supervises.

Selig had already set the tone. He described Louisiana's legal action against the platforms as "naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt." With both sides digging in, the case has become one of the most combative chapters yet in the national struggle over who gets to regulate event contracts.

2. How a state court order led to a federal lawsuit

The dispute traces back to November 12, when Murrill obtained a temporary restraining order from a Louisiana state court. The order was aimed at a long list of companies that offer event contracts to people in Louisiana without holding a state license.

Event contracts let users take positions on whether a specific thing will happen, such as the result of an election, the outcome of a sporting event or a cultural milestone. They are structured as tradable financial instruments, typically paying a fixed amount if the stated outcome occurs and nothing if it does not. Supporters see them as a way to price real-world events. Many state officials see them as wagers under another name.

The court issued the order ex parte, meaning the platforms were not in the courtroom to argue against it before it took effect. It requires the companies to geofence Louisiana, using location checks to block users physically in the state, and to obtain a state license before offering the contracts there.

Temporary restraining orders are short-term measures meant to preserve a situation until a court can hold a fuller hearing. Courts generally grant them only when the party asking shows a risk of immediate harm, and an order issued without the other side present is typically followed quickly by a hearing at which the affected parties can respond. That is why the next court dates in Louisiana carry so much weight.

Days later, the federal government responded. The CFTC and the Justice Department filed a lawsuit in federal court naming Murrill and Louisiana's state gaming regulators as defendants. The complaint argues that Louisiana is trying to impose its own rules on markets that Congress placed under federal supervision.

The CFTC and the Justice Department say the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state rules for markets that the CFTC oversees. In plain terms, they argue that federal law governs these exchanges and overrides any conflicting state requirements, so Louisiana cannot use its gambling statutes to police them.

The Commodity Exchange Act is the main federal law covering futures, options and other derivatives trading in the United States, and the CFTC is the agency that enforces it. Platforms such as Kalshi operate as federally registered exchanges. The federal position is that if event contracts are derivatives listed on markets the agency regulates, then the federal framework controls, and a patchwork of state licensing regimes would undermine it.

The agency's view is that its oversight already covers the concerns states raise, including market integrity, customer protection and manipulation. Requiring each state to license the same contracts separately, the federal side contends, would duplicate that oversight and make it impractical to run a single national exchange.

Preemption arguments of this kind rest on the constitutional principle that valid federal law takes priority over conflicting state law. The open question is whether event contracts on sports, elections and similar outcomes fall within the federal derivatives framework at all, or whether they are gambling that states have always been free to regulate.

4. Why Murrill points to 250 years of state gambling law

Murrill's response leans heavily on history. Her argument is that gambling regulation has been a state responsibility for roughly as long as the country has existed, and that a federal derivatives regulator should not be able to displace that tradition by classifying wagers as financial products.

The framing is strategic. By anchoring the case in long-standing state authority over gambling, Murrill is betting that courts will give weight to that history when they weigh it against the federal preemption claim. It casts Louisiana not as a state trying to block financial innovation, but as one defending powers it has always held.

Her attack on Selig personally adds a political dimension. Calling the CFTC chair an industry standard bearer implies that the agency is protecting the companies rather than the public, a charge that is likely to resonate with other state officials who have raised similar concerns about the rapid growth of prediction markets.

5. Which platforms are caught in the middle?

The companies affected by the Louisiana order include Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini and firms affiliated with Crypto.com. Together they represent much of the U.S. market for event contracts, spanning dedicated prediction market operators and large brokerage and crypto exchange platforms that have added the products.

Many of the contracts these firms offer are tied to popular cultural moments and public events, which is part of why they have drawn so much attention from state authorities. State regulators tend to view such contracts as gambling that should be licensed and taxed like sports betting. The platforms counter that they are offering regulated derivatives on federally supervised exchanges.

Geofencing is not a trivial task. It typically relies on a mix of device location data, network signals and identity checks to confirm where a user is physically located at the moment of a trade. Sports betting operators in states with legal wagering already use such systems, but applying them to a single state on short notice, for a broad set of contract types, adds cost and complexity for every affected platform.

For these companies, the immediate issue is practical rather than philosophical. While the litigation plays out, they must decide whether to build Louisiana-specific geofencing and licensing systems or to pull their products from the state altogether. Either choice carries costs, and the answer could change depending on how the courts rule in the coming weeks.

6. A pattern of federal pushback against the states

Louisiana is not an isolated case. It is the 12th state to face this kind of action from the CFTC, a count that points to a coordinated federal strategy rather than a series of one-off disputes.

The sequence has become familiar. A state applies its gambling laws to restrict or license prediction markets, and the federal government responds that derivatives law takes priority. Each new case adds to the pressure for a definitive answer, whether from the courts or from Congress, on where the line between derivatives and gambling should be drawn.

The number of states involved also shows how quickly the issue has spread. Prediction markets expanded rapidly as more brokerages and exchanges added event contracts, and state officials responsible for gambling oversight have increasingly moved to assert control over products they see as operating outside their licensing systems.

The stakes extend well beyond Louisiana. If federal preemption prevails, platforms will be able to offer event contracts nationwide under a single federal rulebook. If the states prevail, operators could face a patchwork of licensing requirements, geographic restrictions and outright bans that vary from one state line to the next.

7. Why the case matters for crypto regulation

The fight also carries weight for the digital asset industry. Several of the affected companies, including Coinbase, Gemini, Robinhood and firms linked to Crypto.com, are major players in crypto trading, and prediction markets have become an important growth area for them. Polymarket, one of the best-known prediction market brands, grew out of the crypto sector.

The broader question of how far the CFTC's authority reaches is one the crypto industry follows closely. The agency's jurisdiction over derivatives has made it a central regulator for many crypto-related products, and the outcome of the clash with the states will help define how much room federally supervised platforms have to operate without state-by-state approval.

For now, the case adds to a growing list of legal battles that will shape how event contracts are treated in the United States. Each ruling is likely to be cited in the others, which means a decision in Louisiana could influence disputes in other states as well.

8. What's next: court dates on overlapping tracks

The next key date is November 30, when a hearing is scheduled on whether to extend the state court's injunction. Meanwhile, the federal case brought by the CFTC and the Justice Department is moving forward in parallel, which means state and federal courts will be considering the same platforms and the same contracts on overlapping timelines.

That creates the possibility of conflicting outcomes, with a state judge keeping restrictions in place while a federal court weighs whether those restrictions are preempted. Until the courts resolve the conflict, the companies caught in the middle will have to operate in Louisiana under legal uncertainty, and the public exchange between Murrill and Selig suggests neither side is preparing to back down.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY