Regulation•

Fourth Circuit Sides With Maryland Over Kalshi in a 2-1 Vote, the Third Appellate Loss in Four for Prediction Markets

A federal appeals court ruled 2-1 that Maryland can apply its sports-wagering laws to Kalshi, just as a CFTC deadline for nationwide service by prediction markets runs out.

Written By :MINRK
Fourth Circuit Sides With Maryland Over Kalshi in a 2-1 Vote, the Third Appellate Loss in Four for Prediction Markets

Photo by The New York Public Library on Unsplash

1. Kalshi Maryland appeal ends in a 2-1 defeat

Kalshi lost its Maryland appeal on Wednesday, November 18, when the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 that the state may regulate the prediction market under its sports-wagering laws. The decision upholds lower-court rulings and means three of the four federal appellate decisions on the question now favor state oversight.

The outcome adds to a run of prominent courtroom setbacks for prediction markets in the United States. Platforms such as Kalshi let users buy and sell contracts tied to the outcome of real-world events, including sporting contests, and they have argued that federal derivatives law, not state gambling law, governs what they do. Maryland took the opposite view and sought to enforce its own licensing regime against the company. The appellate panel has now agreed that the state is entitled to do so.

The timing is awkward for the industry. A 30-day deadline attached to a demand from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) is close to expiring. That demand asks regulated exchanges to make their contracts available in every state rather than observing the geographic limits that state authorities have ordered. The Fourth Circuit ruling pulls in the opposite direction, confirming that at least one state has the legal authority to impose exactly the kind of restriction the federal regulator wants platforms to stop honoring.

2. What did the Fourth Circuit decide?

The Fourth Circuit decided that Maryland can regulate prediction markets under the state's sports-wagering laws, agreeing with the lower courts that had already reached that conclusion. Two of the three judges on the panel sided with the state, and one did not.

Judge Roger Gregory grounded his reasoning in the long history of states controlling gambling within their borders. He wrote that "the regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power," and said that for this reason he would not infer that Congress had displaced Maryland's concurrent authority.

That framing matters because the dispute is, at its core, a question of preemption: whether a federal statute overrides state law in the same field. Courts are generally cautious about concluding that Congress meant to push states out of an area they have historically policed, and gambling is one of the clearest examples of such an area. Gregory's opinion treats the absence of a clear congressional instruction as decisive. In his reading, federal oversight of derivatives and state oversight of wagering can exist side by side, and Maryland does not lose its authority merely because a product is also listed on a federally regulated exchange.

The panel did not speak with one voice on the reasoning, however. The case produced three separate opinions, a point Kalshi seized on in its response.

3. Maryland frames the ruling as a consumer protection win

State officials presented the result as a matter of equal treatment among companies taking wagers from Maryland residents. Attorney General Anthony Brown said in a statement that Kalshi "must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents."

Brown also set out what those standards involve. Maryland's licensing rules, he said, require sportsbooks to protect customer data, to avoid deceptive advertising, and to stop marketing to people who are barred from betting or who are at risk of gambling harm. He added that "Federal commodities rules were never designed to provide those safeguards."

The argument goes to the practical difference between the two regulatory systems. Federal derivatives oversight was built around market integrity: orderly trading, sound clearing and the prevention of manipulation. State gambling regimes were built around a different set of concerns, including problem gambling, advertising practices and the exclusion of people who should not be placing bets. Maryland's position is that a company offering contracts on sports outcomes to its residents is, for those purposes, doing the same thing a licensed sportsbook does, and should carry the same obligations.

4. Kalshi points to a divided bench

Kalshi's reply focused less on the result than on how the judges arrived at it. "Judges can't agree with each other on why we're wrong," a company spokeswoman said. She argued that the splintered decision, with its three separate opinions, shows there is no unified legal argument against prediction markets.

The company's point reflects a real feature of the litigation so far. Courts around the country have not settled on a single theory for why state law should apply, and the rulings do not line up neatly with one another. Even so, the direction of travel is not favorable to the platforms. A strong majority of the judges who have considered the question are ruling against the industry, and that majority has been growing.

Until the Supreme Court steps in, the conflicting views will leave the regulatory picture unclear. Disagreement among federal appeals courts is one of the classic reasons the justices agree to hear a case, because it means the same federal law is being applied differently depending on where a company or a customer happens to be located. For now, though, prediction markets must operate under a patchwork in which their legal status depends on the state and the court involved.

5. Why is Kalshi being sued by states?

States are pursuing Kalshi because they consider its event contracts, particularly those tied to sports, to be wagering that falls under their own gambling laws. Kalshi and its peers answer that the contracts are federally regulated financial instruments beyond the reach of state gambling authorities.

Both the industry and CFTC Chairman Mike Selig argue that event contracts are swaps traded on regulated derivatives exchanges. On that view, federal law preempts state authority, and a state has no more power to license or ban these contracts than it would have over other products traded on a federally supervised futures exchange.

State officials see it differently. From their perspective, a contract that pays out depending on which team wins a game works like a bet regardless of the legal label attached to it, and the business of accepting such bets from residents has always required a state license. The Maryland case was one test of those competing descriptions, and the Fourth Circuit majority accepted the state's.

The consequences are already visible. Prediction markets are banned in a growing number of states following court orders that favored local authorities. Utah, whose constitution outlaws gambling, is one example.

6. The CFTC ultimatum puts platforms in a bind

A separate pressure point comes from Washington rather than the courts. The CFTC has demanded that regulated exchanges, among them Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase and other operators, offer their contracts in all 50 states instead of honoring state-ordered geographic restrictions. A 30-day deadline for that demand is running out.

The directive leaves the companies facing two unattractive options. Complying could mean defying federal court orders that uphold state restrictions. Refusing could mean running afoul of the federal regulator that supervises their exchanges. A decision like the one in the Maryland case sharpens the conflict, because it is a federal appellate court, not merely a state agency, that has confirmed the state's power to regulate.

Neither side has said how the standoff will be resolved. Kalshi did not respond to a question about how it will respond to the CFTC's nationwide directive. Spokespeople for the CFTC did not immediately say whether the agency will enforce its position against the court rulings.

Selig's position at the agency is unusual in its own right. He is the sole member of a commission that is meant to have five. He is pursuing several prediction-market policies, including rules that would define these contracts in a way that places the space under the federal regulator's control.

7. Senate Democrats push back on the regulator

Congress has also entered the dispute. Democratic senators this week directed the CFTC to back off its ultimatum that platforms return to nationwide service. Those senators will soon hold a majority, which will give them control of Congress's oversight powers.

That political shift gives the intervention more weight than a routine letter from the minority would carry. Oversight authority includes the ability to call agency leaders to testify and to scrutinize how a regulator uses its powers. A chairman acting alone on a commission designed for five members, and pressing companies toward a course that could conflict with federal court orders, is likely to draw close attention from lawmakers who have already signaled that they disagree with the approach.

8. What comes next for prediction markets

Several questions remain open after the Maryland decision. The most immediate is the expiry of the CFTC's 30-day deadline and whether the agency will try to enforce its demand for 50-state service in places where courts have backed state restrictions. The companies' own choices are equally uncertain, since Kalshi has not said how it intends to respond.

The second is the rulemaking that Selig is pursuing. Rules that formally define event contracts as products under the federal regulator's control would strengthen the preemption argument the industry has been making in court, though the Fourth Circuit majority has now indicated it is not persuaded that Congress displaced state authority.

The third, and the one most likely to settle the matter, is the Supreme Court. With appellate courts reaching different conclusions and a strong majority of judges siding with the states, the differing views will keep the regulatory picture murky until the justices intervene. Until then, the legal map for Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase and other operators will continue to be drawn state by state and circuit by circuit, with Maryland now firmly among the jurisdictions where state gambling law applies.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY