Business•

Ryan Cohen Says Disc-Free Releases Hurt Players and GameStop as Grand Theft Auto 6 Arrives With Only a Code in the Box

GameStop chief Ryan Cohen criticized publishers for abandoning physical discs as Grand Theft Auto 6 launched as an $80 download, and backed a US bill on lasting access to purchased games.

Written By :MINRK
Ryan Cohen Says Disc-Free Releases Hurt Players and GameStop as Grand Theft Auto 6 Arrives With Only a Code in the Box

Photo by Raymond Yeung on Unsplash

Mentioned in This Article

BTC
BTC
Bitcoin
$59,027.00
2.12%

1. GameStop's chief takes aim at disc-free releases

GameStop Chief Executive Ryan Cohen has criticized video game publishers for abandoning physical discs, saying the industry's shift to downloads "has hurt consumers, and it's also hurt GameStop." He made the remarks as Grand Theft Auto 6 launched on Thursday, November 19, 2026, with the GTA 6 digital only release priced at $80 and no disc version available.

Cohen, who described the title as one of the most anticipated games ever made, framed his objection around what a buyer is allowed to do after paying. A person who purchases a game, he said in an interview, should be able to sell it, trade it or lend it to someone else. A download tied to an account permits none of those things.

He did not single out any company by name. The timing, however, placed his comments squarely against the biggest release of the year, and the retailer he runs has built a large part of its business on exactly the kind of resale that a download removes.

2. Is GTA 6 digital only?

Yes. Take-Two Interactive, the publisher of Grand Theft Auto 6, is selling the $80 game solely as a download. Retailers still stock boxed copies, but those packages hold a download code and no disc.

Cohen summed up what stores were offering customers who ordered ahead of launch in five words: "It's a code in a box." Take-Two declined to comment on his criticism.

The distinction is more than cosmetic. A disc is a physical object that changes hands freely; once the original buyer is finished with it, the copy can be resold, traded toward another purchase or passed to a friend. A code can be redeemed a single time, after which the game is attached to one account. The box on the shelf looks the same as it always did, but the second-hand market that used to follow every major release has nothing to work with.

3. Trade-ins under pressure at GameStop

Numbers from the retailer's own results show what is at stake. Pre-owned and refurbished products accounted for 22% of GameStop's sales in the quarter that ended on August 1, or about $171 million. That figure was 32% lower than in the same period a year earlier.

The trade-in model has long been central to how specialist game stores operate. A customer brings in a finished game, receives credit, and the store resells the copy at a price below that of a new one. The arrangement gives players a way to recover part of what they spent and gives budget-conscious buyers a cheaper route to recent titles. It also depends entirely on there being a physical product to hand over the counter.

Cohen said publishers defend the move away from discs on the grounds that restricting trade-ins is good for their business, since every used copy sold is a sale that does not go to a new one. His own reading of that argument was blunt: "They're taking away competition."

From a publisher's side of the ledger, the logic is straightforward. A new copy generates revenue for the company that made the game, while a second-hand sale generates revenue only for the store and the previous owner. A download-only release closes off that secondary channel altogether, which is why a decline in pre-owned sales at a chain such as GameStop tracks so closely with the industry's direction.

4. Sony's deadline and the wider retreat from physical media

Grand Theft Auto 6 is the most prominent example of the change, though not the only one. Sony said in July that it will stop producing physical discs for new PlayStation games in January 2028, setting a firm end date for the format on one of the largest console platforms.

That announcement drew criticism of its own. Experts have said low-income gamers will bear the heaviest burden, a group for whom cheaper used copies and the ability to trade in old games have been a practical way to afford new ones. Ken Kutaragi, the founder of PlayStation, characterized the backlash as a "mentality issue."

The push is not new, by one insider's account. A veteran of Infinity Ward, the studio known for the Call of Duty series, said publishers have been working to eliminate discs since 2007. Seen in that light, the launch of the year's biggest game without one is the outcome of a long campaign and not a sudden break.

For retailers, the combination is difficult. A platform holder ending disc production and a leading publisher shipping its flagship title as a code both remove inventory that stores could once buy back and resell. New consoles and accessories still pass through shops, but the recurring cycle of trade-in credit funding the next purchase, which brought customers back to the counter several times a year, weakens with each release that skips the format.

5. A bill in Congress on keeping what you buy

Cohen has taken the argument to Washington. He met with Representative Ritchie Torres, a New York Democrat who is backing the Power to the Players Act. The bill would require companies to give buyers ongoing access to the games they have purchased.

Torres set out the reasoning behind the legislation in October, saying that a game a company is able to take away is "a rental disguised as a sale." The phrase captures the gap between how digital purchases are marketed and what the buyer receives: the checkout page says buy, yet access can depend on a publisher continuing to operate servers or to honor a license.

The proposal addresses a different problem from the one that affects GameStop's resale counter. Guaranteed access would protect a player from losing a game outright, but it would not by itself restore the ability to sell or lend a copy. Cohen's public comments touch on both issues, linking the commercial harm to his company with a broader claim about consumer rights.

6. The ownership fight reaches Europe, the courts and crypto

Pressure on publishers extends beyond the United States. The Stop Killing Games campaign collected 1.3 million signatures for a European Citizens' Initiative, the mechanism that allows citizens of the European Union to ask the European Commission to consider proposing legislation. The campaign's request is that publishers keep games playable once official support for them has ended.

In court, the industry has taken the opposite position. Sony has argued in legal proceedings that digital games cannot be owned, a stance that goes to the core of the dispute. If a download is a license to use software and not a possession, then the rights buyers associate with ownership, including resale, do not automatically follow.

The practical difference shows up when something changes on the seller's side. A disc keeps working for as long as there is hardware to read it, whatever happens to the company that published it. A licensed download depends on the storefront, the account system and, for many modern titles, the servers behind the game continuing to run. That dependence is what both the European campaign and the US bill are trying to address, each from a different angle.

Some participants in the crypto industry have put forward blockchain-based ownership as an answer. The idea is that a game or a license recorded as a token on a public ledger could be held in a user's own wallet and transferred to another person, recreating in digital form the resale and lending that discs made possible. The concept has been pitched as a solution, though the dispute for now is playing out in legislatures, petitions and courtrooms.

7. GameStop's Bitcoin holdings and eBay ambitions

The retailer has been reshaping itself while its traditional business faces these headwinds. GameStop bought 4,710 Bitcoin (BTC) for more than $500 million in 2025, joining the group of public companies that hold the asset on their balance sheets.

In March, the company moved all but one of those coins into a covered call strategy on Coinbase Prime in order to generate income. In a covered call, the holder of an asset sells call options against it and collects the premiums. The seller earns a steady payment in exchange for giving up part of the gain if the price climbs above the level set in the option contract.

GameStop has also pursued a far larger target. In May, after eBay rejected its takeover offer, the company asked shareholders to approve an increase in its authorized share count to 2.5 billion while it built a stake in the online marketplace. Raising the number of authorized shares gives a company room to issue new stock, which can be used to raise capital or to pay for acquisitions.

8. What happens next

Three developments will shape how the argument unfolds. The first is the Power to the Players Act, which Torres is backing in Congress and which would write a right of continued access into US law if it advances. The second is Sony's stated deadline of January 2028 for ending production of physical discs for new PlayStation games, which would extend the disc-free model across a major platform. The third is the European initiative, where 1.3 million signatures have put the question of keeping games playable in front of EU institutions.

For GameStop, the more immediate measure is its own reporting. Pre-owned and refurbished sales had already fallen 32% in the quarter to August 1, before the year's most anticipated game arrived with nothing for customers to trade back in. Cohen's remarks make clear that he sees the two as connected, and that he intends to press the case on behalf of both his company and the players who shop there.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY