Regulation•

Germany's Bundestag Backs Letting Customs Freeze Crypto Above €100,000 With No Criminal Case

The Bundestag approved a bill on November 12 allowing customs to freeze crypto and other assets above €100,000 of doubtful origin without charges. Bar associations object; the Bundesrat must still approve.

Written By :MINRK
Germany's Bundestag Backs Letting Customs Freeze Crypto Above €100,000 With No Criminal Case

Photo by Dima on Unsplash

1. Germany crypto laws could soon allow freezes without charges

Germany's lower house of parliament, the Bundestag, approved a bill on November 12 that would let customs officers freeze crypto and other assets worth more than €100,000 ($116,000) when their lawful origin is in doubt, without first opening a criminal case. The measure still needs approval from the upper house, the Bundesrat, before a planned January 1 start.

The legislation forms part of a wider effort against money laundering and organized crime. It is not written for digital assets alone. Its target is high-value property of unclear origin in general, with crypto named among the assets it reaches.

Two of the country's main legal associations have come out against it. Their objection is that the bill hands customs broad discretion and risks placing the burden of proof on the holder of the assets instead of on the authorities.

2. How would the asset freeze work?

Customs officers could freeze assets above the threshold whenever they have reasonable doubts that the property was lawfully obtained. No criminal investigation or charge would be required as a first step. That is the feature that sets the bill apart from the conventional route, in which assets are secured in connection with a suspected offense.

The freeze would be temporary at the outset. Customs could hold suspicious assets for an initial 30 days. A court could then extend that period by a further 150 days, bringing the possible total to 180 days before a final outcome.

Permanent confiscation is treated separately. Taking assets away for good would require a court decision, so customs could not strip an owner of property on its own authority. The administrative power is limited to holding the assets in place while their origin is examined.

The threshold applies to value, set at more than €100,000. Holdings below that level fall outside the measure. For crypto, the bill specifically covers assets as defined under the European Union's Markets in Crypto-Assets regulation, known as MiCA, which is the bloc's common rulebook for the sector.

Two elements therefore have to be present before the power can be used: an asset valued above the threshold, and reasonable doubt on the part of customs about whether it was lawfully obtained. Neither element requires evidence of a particular crime. The trigger is uncertainty about origin, which is a different and lower standard than the suspicion of an identified offense that normally underpins a criminal inquiry.

3. Why crypto is named alongside other high-value assets

Lawmakers did not draft a crypto-specific seizure law. They wrote a general measure on valuable property of unclear origin and made sure digital assets were covered by it. Tying the definition to MiCA gives customs a ready-made legal description of what counts as a crypto asset, so the German text does not have to construct one of its own.

The inclusion reflects how regulators now treat digital holdings: as one more store of wealth that can be used to park or move the proceeds of crime, in the same way as cash, valuables or other property. A measure aimed at organized crime and money laundering that left crypto out would have an obvious gap.

For holders, the consequence is that crypto wealth is placed on the same footing as other assets when it comes to explaining where it came from. The €100,000 line means the measure is directed at substantial balances. An investor with a modest position is not affected, while anyone whose holdings exceed that value, whether through purchases or through appreciation over time, is within the range the bill addresses.

4. The government's case for the measure

The reasoning offered for the bill rests on a simple premise. According to the parliament's summary of the legislation, the government's position is that people who hold substantial assets should generally be able to explain how they came by them.

From that standpoint, a request to account for the source of a large holding is not an accusation. It is presented as a reasonable expectation attached to significant wealth, and the freeze is the tool that preserves the assets while the explanation is sought.

The approach reflects a difficulty that authorities face in laundering cases. Proving the specific crime that generated a sum of money can be hard, particularly when funds have passed through several hands or jurisdictions. A power that focuses on the asset and its unexplained origin, and not on a named offense, is designed to work around that obstacle. The same feature is what alarms the bill's critics.

5. Why German lawyers say the burden of proof is being reversed

The Federal Bar Association, known by its German abbreviation BRAK, opposes the measure. It argues that the bill gives the authorities too much room to question how assets were acquired.

BRAK's particular concern is documentation. It warns that missing paperwork should not be treated as evidence that property has an illegal origin, and it points to inherited property as an example. Assets passed down within a family may come with incomplete records, and the absence of a paper trail in such a case says nothing about criminality.

The German Bar Association, the DAV, has also rejected the proposal. In a statement issued in November, it noted that authorities would be able to step in where the lawful origin of assets appears "not plausible." That wording, in the association's reading, sets a low and subjective bar for intervention.

The DAV raised a structural objection as well. Its statement criticized the expansion of customs powers and the transfer of police functions to the customs service. Under the bill, an agency traditionally associated with border and trade enforcement would take on a role in probing private wealth.

Taken together, the two associations describe a shift in who must prove what. In a criminal case, the state has to show that an offense took place. Under the bill as the lawyers read it, a holder whose assets are frozen would in practice need to demonstrate that the property is clean in order to have it released.

6. What the bill means for crypto holders

Digital assets present the documentation problem in a sharp form. A person who bought tokens years ago, moved them between wallets or platforms, or received them from another individual may not have a complete record of each step. Platforms close, account histories become unavailable, and early purchases were often made with little thought to future proof.

That is why the legal associations' warning about missing records resonates beyond inheritance cases. If an incomplete history can be read as a sign that lawful origin is not plausible, long-term holders with large balances could find themselves asked to reconstruct transactions for which evidence is thin.

The bill does not single out crypto for harsher treatment than other property. The same threshold and the same test apply to any high-value asset of unclear origin. Even so, the explicit reference to crypto as defined under MiCA makes clear that digital holdings are squarely within reach of the new customs power.

Andrew Withworth, founder and director of the London-based regulatory advisory firm Global Policy, said the practical issue is "what will count as proof of lawful origin." In his view, that question is one for German finance courts to settle and falls outside what European crypto regulation determines. MiCA defines the assets and governs the firms that deal in them. It does not say what evidence a customs officer or a judge must accept when an owner explains where a holding came from.

The point underlines how much of the bill's real effect will depend on application. A standard that accepts exchange statements, tax filings and wallet records as sufficient would leave most holders with a workable path. A stricter standard would make the freeze far harder to lift.

7. How the freeze differs from confiscation

The distinction between freezing and confiscating runs through the debate. A freeze prevents the owner from moving or disposing of the assets for a limited time. Ownership does not change. Confiscation ends ownership, and the bill reserves that step for the courts.

For the government, this separation is a safeguard: customs can act quickly to stop assets from disappearing, while a judge decides anything permanent. For critics, the safeguard arrives late. A freeze lasting up to 180 days, counting the initial 30 days and the possible 150-day extension, can itself impose heavy costs on someone whose property turns out to be legitimate.

The initial 30-day period requires no court involvement under the terms described in the parliament's summary. Judicial review enters at the extension stage. The lawyers' groups argue that the threshold for the first step, reasonable doubt about lawful origin, leaves considerable room for an officer's judgment before any judge is involved.

8. What happens next in the Bundesrat?

The bill now goes to the Bundesrat, the upper house representing Germany's federal states, which is expected to take up the legislation. Its approval is required before the law can take effect.

The planned implementation date is January 1. That leaves a short window for the upper house to act and for the objections raised by BRAK and the DAV to be weighed.

If the measure passes in its current form, the next phase of the argument will move to the courts. Judges would decide on extensions of individual freezes and on any permanent confiscation, and through those cases they would define what counts as an adequate explanation of where assets came from. As Withworth indicated, that evidentiary question is the one with the greatest practical consequence for people holding more than €100,000 in crypto in Germany.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY