Mentioned in This Article
1. Fed rate hike plans collide with falling fuel prices
A Fed rate hike in December is drawing criticism from market strategists who say the central bank is acting on stale numbers. Minutes published on Wednesday, November 18, showed almost all Federal Reserve officials expect further increases, yet wholesale gasoline futures have dropped about 20% in three weeks and the average US pump price stood at $3.75 a gallon on Thursday, November 19.
The disagreement comes down to timing. Policymakers are responding to October readings of consumer and producer prices, which showed inflation spreading across everyday goods and services. Their critics counter that those reports describe what households and businesses paid weeks ago, while energy markets that trade every day have already turned sharply lower. If the critics are right, the Federal Reserve risks tightening policy at the moment one of the largest sources of this year's inflation is fading.
Energy has been at the center of the inflation problem since the war involving Iran began in early March, pushing up the cost of crude oil and refined fuels. That history explains why a reversal in fuel prices matters so much to the argument: the same channel that lifted headline inflation through the spring and summer could now work in the opposite direction.
2. What the October minutes and Fed officials said
Wednesday's record of the October policy meeting left little doubt about where the committee is leaning. According to the minutes, almost all participants judged that additional increases in interest rates would likely be appropriate over the coming months in order to bring inflation back to the central bank's 2% objective.
Two officials were prepared to go further than the usual pace. They raised the possibility of a December move of more than 25 basis points if the inflation data arriving before that meeting proved disappointing. A basis point is one-hundredth of a percentage point, so 25 basis points equals the quarter-point step the Federal Reserve normally uses when it adjusts its benchmark rate.
Public remarks since the meeting have reinforced the message. Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller said in a television interview early Wednesday that he supports a 50-basis-point increase in December, twice the standard size. Governor Michael Barr said higher rates would likely be appropriate, while San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly argued for a measured approach.
The officials are reacting chiefly to the October consumer price index (CPI) and producer price index (PPI). Both reports indicated that price pressures were no longer confined to energy and had broadened into a wider range of goods and services, the kind of development that typically worries a central bank because it suggests inflation is becoming embedded.
3. Why do analysts think the Fed is reading the wrong data?
Critics argue that CPI and PPI are backward-looking measures that record prices already paid, while live market gauges such as refining margins, gasoline futures and pump prices show where costs are heading. On that view, the Federal Reserve is falling behind the curve by steering policy with indicators that lag the real economy by weeks.
Thierry Borgeat, co-founder and chief investment officer of Arvy, a Zurich-based asset manager regulated by the Swiss financial supervisor FINMA, put the case directly. Inflation reports, he said, tell policymakers what people spent in the past, whereas the crack spread signals what they will pay in the future. In his words, the Federal Reserve is 'about to hike into falling prices at the pump,' relying on the lagging indicator rather than the leading one.
The October inflation reports were compiled before the latest slide in energy and other commodities, the critics note. That means the data shaping the December debate does not yet capture the decline in fuel costs that drivers are already seeing at filling stations, and it will not do so until November's figures are published.
4. What is the crack spread and why is it falling?
The crack spread is the profit a refiner earns from turning crude oil into fuel: the difference between what a barrel of crude costs and what the gasoline and diesel made from it sell for. When that margin narrows, fuel prices are falling faster than crude, and prices at the pump usually follow.
The most widely watched version is the 3-2-1 spread, which assumes that three barrels of crude yield two barrels of gasoline and one barrel of diesel. That measure has dropped 36% in six weeks, from $65.56 a barrel to $41.90 as of Wednesday, according to James E. Thorne, chief market strategist at wealth management firm Wellington Altus.
Thorne said the pressure has migrated downstream. Unusually wide refining margins earlier in the year encouraged refiners to run their plants at full capacity, and the resulting output has left markets for refined products oversupplied. Gasoline and diesel are therefore losing value more quickly than the crude they are made from, a shift that wholesale gasoline futures and retail prices had already begun to signal.
He characterized the situation as a glut of supply rather than a weakness in demand, and described raising rates while refining margins are collapsing as unwise. The distinction matters for policy: higher interest rates work by cooling demand, and they do little to address a price move that is being driven by excess supply.
5. Gasoline futures and pump prices are sliding
Evidence from the futures market points the same way. RBOB futures, the wholesale gasoline benchmark traded on the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX), fell 11.1% and then 6.1% over the last two completed weeks, a combined decline of roughly 16.5%. They have lost a further 4.4% so far this week, bringing the three-week drop to nearly 20%, the steepest since March 2020.
Retail prices are following with a delay. The national average for regular gasoline tracked by the motoring group AAA was $3.75 a gallon on Thursday. That is 12.8% lower than a month earlier and 4.9% lower than a week earlier, although it remains about 22% higher than at the same point last year.
Thorne expects more relief because prices at the pump tend to trail wholesale prices by several weeks. By his estimate, every 10-cent decline in gasoline removes about 9 basis points from headline CPI. He anticipates a negative headline inflation reading for November and noted that the price spike that followed the start of the war in March will eventually fall out of year-over-year comparisons, mechanically lowering the annual rate.
6. Commodity funds show a broader retreat
Gasoline is not the only raw material losing ground this month. Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Investment Research, compiled month-to-date performance for a range of commodity exchange-traded funds as of Wednesday's close. Such funds hold futures contracts, so their returns can differ from moves in spot prices, but the direction was consistent across most of the group.
A fund tracking gasoline was down 20.9%, one tracking US crude oil had fallen 19.4% and a Brent crude fund was 18.7% lower. Broad commodity funds had lost about 12%. Among individual markets, a copper fund was down 12.5%, wheat 4.6%, corn 2.7% and gold 4.1%.
Natural gas was the exception, with a fund tied to that market up 16.9% over the same period. Outside that single case, the figures describe a decline that extends from energy into industrial metals, grains and precious metals, which is why the analysts argue that the easing of price pressure is broader than one fuel.
7. What the debate means for Bitcoin and risk assets
For digital asset investors, the dispute over inflation data is more than an academic argument. Higher interest rates raise borrowing costs across the economy and tend to weigh on risk assets, a category that includes Bitcoin (BTC). Expectations of additional tightening have been acting as a headwind for the cryptocurrency, which makes the path of Federal Reserve policy one of the main macroeconomic variables traders are watching.
Some market participants suspect the central bank's tone is partly tactical. James Lavish, co-managing partner of the Bitcoin Opportunity Fund, suggested the Federal Reserve may be leaning on markets verbally, keeping its language hawkish even as energy prices ease so that it can justify bringing the rate increases to a halt later. That reading is an interpretation held by some investors rather than anything officials have stated.
The analysts' case rests on the lag between wholesale and retail prices and on the expectation that the coming inflation reports will reflect cheaper fuel. Policymakers, for their part, have pointed to the breadth of October's price increases, which went beyond energy. Which of the two readings proves correct will shape the outlook for rates and, by extension, for assets that are sensitive to them.
8. What comes next for interest rates
Attention now turns to the Federal Reserve's December meeting and to the inflation data that will arrive before it. The minutes made clear that at least two officials would consider a move larger than a quarter point if those numbers disappoint, and Waller has already said publicly that he favors a half-point step.
Interest-rate futures are priced for a steadier course. At the time of the latest readings, they implied quarter-point increases in December and in January, with another by April. That pricing suggests traders expect the tightening to continue but have not embraced the larger move some officials have floated.
The November CPI report will be the first to capture the bulk of the recent decline in gasoline. If Thorne's projection of a negative headline print is borne out, the argument that policymakers are responding to outdated information would gain weight. If inflation instead continues to broaden across goods and services as it did in October, the committee's preference for further increases would be easier to defend.
