Mentioned in This Article
1. Enterprise Blockchain Deserves a Second Attempt, Brody Argues
Enterprise blockchain is ready for a comeback, Paul Brody, founder and chief executive of Nightfall Networks and former global blockchain leader at EY, argued in an opinion piece published on November 15, 2026. He contends that the corporate blockchain projects that collapsed between 2017 and 2023 were premature rather than misguided, and that scalability, privacy and onchain liquidity have since matured enough to make them work.
Brody is not a neutral observer. Nightfall Networks builds privacy systems for businesses that want to operate on public blockchains, and he previously chaired the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance, an industry group formed to promote corporate use of Ethereum technology. His case is nonetheless a detailed one: it rests on a diagnosis of why the first generation of enterprise blockchain projects failed, and on a claim that the specific obstacles they faced have now largely been removed.
The argument arrives at a moment when much of the business world has written off the idea. Large consortia backed by banks and technology giants announced ambitious networks during the last decade, only to shut them down within a few years. For many executives, the lesson drawn from that period was simple: blockchain did not work for business. Brody wants to replace that conclusion with a different one.
2. The Pets.com Lesson: Timing, Not Folly
Brody frames his case through one of the best-known failures of the dot-com era. Pets.com raised about $110 million from Amazon and other investors before it collapsed, and its demise was widely blamed on a basic problem of economics: heavy bags of dog food are expensive to ship to individual homes. At the time, the company became shorthand for the idea that selling pet supplies online could never pay.
Two decades later, that verdict looks very different. Brody points to Chewy, the online pet retailer, which reported $12.6 billion in sales and about $223 million in net income for its most recent fiscal year. The model that supposedly could not work now supports a large and profitable public company.
The real lesson of Pets.com, in Brody's telling, is about timing. The concept was sound, but it arrived before the logistics networks, consumer habits and unit economics needed to support it were in place. He believes the crypto industry spent comparable sums between 2017 and 2023 pursuing enterprise blockchain, and that the dozens of companies involved were not foolish, simply too early.
3. What Problem Is Enterprise Blockchain Meant to Solve?
Enterprise blockchain is meant to fix what happens when information has to cross from one company to another. Brody's starting point is that business systems tend to work well inside a single organization and break down at its edges, where suppliers, customers, banks and logistics providers all keep their own records.
He describes two common ways companies cope today. The first is informal: information is passed along through text messages, emails and spreadsheets attached to messages. That approach is cheap and flexible, but the records held by different parties frequently drift out of sync, so each company's version of events is often slightly wrong.
The second approach is the opposite. A dominant company in an industry builds an expensive, always-on proprietary integration and asks its suppliers to connect to it. These systems keep data aligned, but they are costly to build and maintain, and they leave smaller partners locked into a platform controlled by someone else. Brody compares the dependence that results to Stockholm syndrome.
Blockchain, as he describes its original promise, offered a third path: a shared record of information and business logic that every participant in an open ecosystem could see and rely on, providing real-time visibility without tying anyone to a single vendor. Around 2017, he writes, that promise seemed obvious.
4. Why the First Wave of Consortia Collapsed
Despite the early enthusiasm, a long list of high-profile networks faded within a few years. Brody names TradeLens, We.Trade, Contour, B3i, the Australian Securities Exchange's CHESS replacement project and Everledger among them. A quick search, he says, turned up 18 failed efforts, several of them backed by major institutions including Deutsche Bank, HSBC and IBM.
The common thread, in his analysis, was privacy. Public blockchains are transparent by design: every transaction is visible to anyone who looks. That property is useful for an open financial system, but it is a serious problem for businesses. No company wants its competitors to see its prices, volumes, suppliers or customers.
To work around that, builders turned to private or permissioned blockchains and added layers of conventional technology to keep sensitive data hidden. According to Brody, those workarounds made the systems slow and expensive, and they never gained enough traction to justify their cost. The backing of large banks and technology companies could not overcome the underlying design mismatch.
The handful of firms that survived, he notes, have largely "de-chained," quietly reverting to standard software-as-a-service products. The people who used the original systems often came away convinced that blockchain itself was the problem.
5. Scalability Is No Longer the Bottleneck
Brody's central claim is that the conditions behind those failures have changed. The first change he cites is capacity. In 2020, the Ethereum network processed roughly 1 million transactions a day, and fees periodically spiked to between $30 and $50 per transaction, levels that made routine business use impractical.
Today, he writes, most transactions cost less than a penny, and capacity is on a path toward billions of transactions a day as scaling technology matures. The so-called blockchain trilemma, the long-running debate over whether a network can be secure, decentralized and scalable at the same time, has largely dropped out of the conversation.
For enterprise use, that shift matters because supply chains and payment flows generate enormous numbers of small records. A system that charges tens of dollars per entry, or that slows down whenever demand rises, cannot replace spreadsheets or electronic data interchange. A system that costs fractions of a cent per entry can.
6. Privacy Tools Have Caught Up
The second change, and the one most closely tied to Brody's own business, is privacy. He acknowledges that privacy is still not the default on public blockchains, but argues that workable tools now exist. He points to privacy pools, zero-knowledge rollups and full privacy chains as examples.
Zero-knowledge technology allows one party to prove that a statement is true without revealing the underlying data. For a business, that can mean confirming that an invoice was paid or a shipment delivered without exposing the amount, the counterparty or other commercial details to the rest of the network.
Brody also notes that Ethereum is adding basic privacy features at several layers of its technology stack. In his view, those developments make it feasible for companies to run large-scale private business operations on public infrastructure, which is precisely what the first generation of enterprise projects could not do.
7. Stablecoins Bring Money Onchain
The third change is liquidity. Brody argues that assets are steadily moving onto blockchains and that regulators have endorsed stablecoins, giving businesses a form of digital money that can move on the same networks as their operational data.
He cites stablecoin transaction volume of just under $1.8 trillion in June, based on Visa's adjusted figures, which strip out activity such as bot trading and internal exchange transfers. That scale, in his view, shows that onchain payments have moved well beyond experimentation.
The significance for enterprise blockchain is that operations and finance can finally sit in one place. Under the earlier model, a shared ledger might track a purchase order or a shipment, but payment still had to travel through separate banking systems. With stablecoins available on the same network, Brody argues, companies can buy, sell, move assets and get paid within a single ecosystem.
8. What Can Enterprise Blockchain Be Used For?
Brody sees the clearest uses in inventory management, contract administration and working capital. On inventory, he says his own experience suggests that replacing spreadsheets and electronic data interchange with shared onchain records could cut inventory by about 20% while keeping the same level of service, a reduction he says would be worth billions of dollars in freed-up working capital.
On contracts, he argues that smart contracts can reduce the time needed to apply contract rules from days to minutes and cut administration costs in half. He points to a royalty system built for Microsoft's Xbox business, which shortened the time partners needed to access their royalty statements from 45 days to four minutes.
On financing, Brody describes onchain purchase orders and invoices as a way for suppliers to prove the quality of the buyers they sell to, which could help them obtain cheaper credit. The same records could allow receivables to be sold to financiers immediately and efficiently, rather than after lengthy verification.
9. The Case for Trying Again
Brody's conclusion is direct: the returns and use cases are clear, and it is time to try again. His argument does not deny that the first wave of enterprise blockchain failed. Instead, it reframes that failure as a problem of timing, in the same way that Pets.com's collapse now looks less like proof that online pet supplies were doomed and more like a business that arrived ahead of its infrastructure.
Whether corporate buyers accept that reframing remains an open question. Many of the executives who backed the earlier consortia saw large investments produce little, and the perception that blockchain did not work for business is deeply rooted. Brody's case rests on the claim that cheap transactions, practical privacy and onchain money together remove the barriers that sank those projects.
For the crypto industry, the debate matters beyond any single company. If enterprises return to public blockchains for supply chain records, contracts and payments, they would bring a steady stream of real economic activity to networks that have so far been dominated by trading and speculation. Brody is betting that the second attempt will look more like Chewy than Pets.com.
