Regulation•

Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Must Face DRAM Supply Conspiracy Claims After Judge Rejects Dismissal

A federal judge refused to dismiss a class action alleging Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron conspired to cut conventional DRAM supply, sending the case into discovery.

Written By :MINRK
Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Must Face DRAM Supply Conspiracy Claims After Judge Rejects Dismissal

Photo by Harrison Broadbent on Unsplash

1. DRAM Lawsuit Clears Its First Major Hurdle

A federal judge in San Jose on November 14, 2026, refused to dismiss a class-action DRAM lawsuit accusing Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix and Micron Technology of conspiring to restrict memory chip supply. US District Judge Noël Wise's ruling sends the case into discovery, where internal company records can be sought.

The decision does not find that the three chipmakers did anything wrong. It holds only that the plaintiffs have described a plausible conspiracy, enough to let the case move forward. That threshold matters, because the next phase gives the plaintiffs access to tools they did not have when they filed: the ability to request internal emails, planning documents and other records that could show how and why production decisions were made.

For years, the price of memory chips has been shaped almost entirely by the decisions of the companies that make them. With this ruling, a federal courtroom in Northern California now has a role in that story too. The companies at the center of the case dominate one of the most important components in modern electronics, and the lawsuit questions whether their recent output choices were truly independent.

2. Who Is Suing and What They Want

Seventeen consumers and small businesses brought the suit on June 25, 2026, alleging that the three manufacturers agreed to curb the supply of conventional DRAM. That is the dynamic random-access memory found in laptops, smartphones and servers, the working memory that lets devices run applications and process data.

The plaintiffs are indirect purchasers. They did not buy memory chips straight from Samsung, SK Hynix or Micron. Instead, they bought finished products, such as computers and phones, that contained those chips. Their argument is that any artificial increase in memory prices was passed down the supply chain and ultimately paid by people like them.

Indirect purchaser claims are a familiar feature of antitrust litigation in the technology sector, because most people never buy components on their own. A memory chip typically passes through several hands, from the manufacturer to a module maker or device assembler and then to a retailer, before it reaches the end user inside a finished product. The plaintiffs contend that higher costs at the start of that chain flowed all the way to the end.

The group is seeking damages to compensate for the higher prices it says it paid, as well as injunctive relief, a court order that would bar the conduct it alleges. The case is being brought as a class action, meaning the named plaintiffs aim to represent a much broader group of buyers who were affected in the same way.

3. How Concentrated Is the DRAM Market?

The DRAM market is extraordinarily concentrated: Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron together accounted for more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025.

That level of concentration is central to the case. When three firms control nearly an entire market, each company's decisions about how much to produce can move prices for everyone. Economists describe such markets as oligopolies. In an oligopoly, companies can sometimes arrive at similar behavior simply by watching one another, without ever agreeing to anything. That is legal. What antitrust law prohibits is an actual agreement among competitors to limit output or fix prices.

Because the market is so tightly held, buyers have few alternatives when supply tightens. A consumer or business that needs memory, whether directly or inside a finished device, cannot easily turn to another major supplier if all three leading producers cut back at roughly the same time.

4. The Alleged Timeline of Production Cuts

The complaint traces the alleged scheme to late 2022, when the three companies began reducing output of conventional DRAM in quick succession.

SK Hynix and Micron announced their cuts about three weeks apart in late 2022, according to the plaintiffs. Samsung followed in April 2023. The plaintiffs view this sequence as a pattern of coordinated restraint rather than a series of unrelated business decisions.

The suit further alleges that the companies redirected manufacturing capacity away from conventional DRAM and toward high-bandwidth memory, known as HBM. HBM is a premium form of memory designed for artificial intelligence workloads, stacking chips to deliver the speed that AI processors require. It commands far higher margins than standard memory.

According to the complaint, the combined effect of reduced conventional output was dramatic. The plaintiffs allege that prices for conventional DRAM climbed by as much as 697%. For buyers of everyday devices, that kind of increase in a core component can translate into higher prices across a wide range of products.

5. What Is a Motion to Dismiss?

A motion to dismiss is a request by a defendant asking the court to throw out a case at the outset, on the grounds that even if every allegation in the complaint were true, the facts described would not add up to a violation of the law.

At this stage, a judge does not weigh evidence or decide who is telling the truth. The question is narrower: taking the complaint at face value, does it describe a legal claim that could succeed? If the answer is no, the case ends. If the answer is yes, it proceeds.

Judge Wise concluded that the allegations here were plausible and that they justified moving to discovery. Her ruling also distinguished this lawsuit from an earlier case that had been dismissed, pointing to the particular circumstances the current plaintiffs allege. That distinction was important, because the defendants could otherwise have argued that the courts had already rejected a similar theory.

The legal standard explains why the ruling is significant but limited. In antitrust cases, parallel conduct, such as competitors cutting production at around the same time, is not illegal on its own. Companies facing the same market conditions may reasonably make similar choices. To succeed, plaintiffs generally need evidence that points toward an actual agreement rather than coincidence or independent reaction to shared circumstances. Discovery is where they will look for it.

6. No Liability Has Been Established

Nothing in the ruling means the chipmakers broke the law. No court has found any of the three companies liable, and the case remains at an early procedural stage.

The defendants maintain that their production decisions reflected changing market conditions, not an agreement among rivals. In their account, cutting output of conventional memory and expanding production of a newer, more profitable product is a rational response to demand, the kind of decision any business might make independently.

That framing gives the companies a straightforward line of defense. Pursuing higher margins in a fast-growing product category is ordinary commercial behavior. The burden falls on the plaintiffs to show that the move into HBM was coordinated among the three companies rather than something each arrived at on its own.

7. A Familiar Industry Faces Familiar Questions

This is not the first time these companies have faced price-fixing allegations. The defendants were part of an earlier DRAM price-fixing cartel that operated from 1998 to 2002 and led to significant penalties.

That history gives the current case a resonance it might otherwise lack, though it does not establish anything about the present allegations. Past conduct is not proof of current wrongdoing, and the legal questions must be decided on the facts of this case.

The context has also changed considerably. The earlier cartel centered on memory for personal computers, at a time when the PC was the main driver of chip demand. The current allegations revolve around a market reshaped by artificial intelligence, in which data center builders are competing for HBM to power AI systems. The pull of that demand is at the heart of both the plaintiffs' theory and the companies' defense: one side sees it as cover for coordinated restraint, the other as the natural reason a business would shift its capacity.

8. What the DRAM Lawsuit Means for Investors

For shareholders in Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron, the near-term consequence is legal uncertainty rather than any verdict. The ruling adds an overhang that is likely to persist for some time.

Discovery in complex antitrust cases is often lengthy and expensive. It can involve the review of large volumes of internal communications, depositions of executives and extensive expert analysis. Beyond the direct cost, it carries reputational risk: documents produced in discovery can shape public perception of a company, regardless of how the case is ultimately resolved.

For the wider market, the case adds scrutiny to the practices of an industry that sits at the center of the AI build-out. Memory is a critical input for everything from consumer devices to the largest data centers, and questions about how supply is managed have implications well beyond the courtroom.

9. What Comes Next in the Case

The next key date is December 7, 2026, when the defendants' formal answers to the complaint are due. Those filings will show in writing how the three companies intend to frame their defense.

After that, the court has scheduled its first case-management conference for January 12, 2027. That hearing is expected to set the timetable for discovery, establishing how the parties will exchange documents and information in the months ahead.

Neither date is expected to resolve the central question of whether an agreement existed. Answers to a complaint usually admit or deny each allegation and set out the defenses a company plans to raise, while an initial conference deals with scheduling and procedure rather than the merits.

Between those milestones, the case enters the phase that could prove decisive. The plaintiffs now have the opportunity to search for evidence of an agreement behind the production cuts, while the chipmakers will seek to show that each acted on its own reading of a rapidly changing market.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY