Regulation•

Patrick Witt Says the Clarity Act Ran Out of Time and Hands US Crypto Rulemaking to the SEC and CFTC

Former White House crypto adviser Patrick Witt blames the calendar and an ethics fight for the Clarity Act's Senate defeat, and expects the SEC and CFTC to write the rules instead.

Written By :MINRK
Patrick Witt Says the Clarity Act Ran Out of Time and Hands US Crypto Rulemaking to the SEC and CFTC

Photo by Ian Hutchinson on Unsplash

Mentioned in This Article

SOL
SOL
Solana
$74.88
2.86%

1. Clarity Act defeat draws a blunt verdict from its chief negotiator

Patrick Witt, who until October led the President's Council of Advisers for Digital Assets, has described the Senate's failure to pass the Clarity Act as a "failure of American leadership." In remarks made public on November 16, 2026, he said the crypto market structure bill "lost against the clock" and predicted that the SEC and CFTC will now set the rules.

Witt delivered the assessment during an on-stage interview at Solana's Breakpoint conference in London. He was not speaking as a detached observer. As executive director of the council, he ran the White House campaign to get the legislation through Congress, and he told the audience he had spent more than a year at the negotiating table.

He called the result "extremely disappointing" and said the bill "would have been incredibly impactful" had it reached the president's desk. The legislation was designed to create a framework for how crypto markets are regulated in the United States, a question the industry has pressed lawmakers to settle for years. It stalled in September, when it failed a key procedural vote in the Senate.

2. Why did the Clarity Act fail?

In Witt's telling, the Clarity Act failed because time ran out, not because the two sides were far apart on substance. He said the policy disagreements had largely been worked through by the end, and that what sank the bill was the approach of the midterm elections combined with a single dispute that crowded out everything else.

That dispute was about ethics. Democrats had raised objections to the crypto ventures connected to President Donald Trump's family, and Witt acknowledged that the president's own involvement in the sector was "arguably the issue." As the election drew closer, he said, the ethics question "really consumed everything else," leaving little room for the remaining work on the bill.

The former adviser did not present this as a case of the White House refusing to give ground. He said Trump had agreed to two separate ethics provisions covering his crypto holdings. Even so, the concessions were not enough to move the bill past the Senate's procedural hurdle before the campaign season closed the window.

A procedural vote of this kind is the step that allows a bill to advance toward final consideration. Losing one does not always end a bill's life, but it removes momentum at the moment legislation needs it most, and it leaves sponsors dependent on finding floor time later. For a bill negotiated against an election deadline, there was no later.

3. What the ethics provisions would have required

Witt gave details on the second of the two provisions the president accepted. It would have barred federal officials, with the president explicitly included, from issuing or sponsoring digital assets. It would also have required the president to divest certain digital assets or move them into a blind trust.

Enforcement was part of the package as well. Under the provision, state attorneys general would have been able to act on violations, which would have placed a check on federal officials outside the federal government itself.

Witt stressed how unusual these terms were, saying there is "no precedent" for such measures in United States law. His point was that the administration had accepted restrictions on the presidency that had not existed before, and that the bill still fell short. He did not spell out the contents of the first provision in the interview.

The episode shows how closely the fate of market structure legislation became tied to questions about personal financial interests at the top of the executive branch. A bill that began as a technical effort to divide oversight of digital assets ended up being judged, at least in its final weeks, on a different question entirely.

4. The GENIUS comparison and a single chance

Supporters of crypto legislation have seen a bill recover from an early setback before. The GENIUS stablecoin bill also lost an initial procedural vote in 2025, only to pass later. That history gave some in the industry reason to think the Clarity Act could follow the same path.

Witt explained why it did not. The difference, he said, came down to timing. GENIUS moved early in Trump's term, when there was still room on the calendar to regroup, rebuild a coalition and return to the floor. The Clarity Act reached its decisive vote with the midterms close at hand and no comparable margin for a second attempt.

He said his team understood this while the negotiations were under way. They knew the Clarity Act would get one opportunity, and in his words they "came up short." The acknowledgment was notable for its directness from an official who had been responsible for the outcome.

5. Who will regulate crypto now?

Witt expects the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, not Congress, to write the rules for United States crypto markets. He put the chances of lawmakers passing a comprehensive replacement for the Clarity Act as low, and said market structure will be shaped less on Capitol Hill and more through agency rulemaking and guidance published in the Federal Register.

That does not mean every idea in the bill is finished. Witt said pieces of the Clarity Act could still travel inside larger legislative packages. Lawmakers could also choose to hand out narrower, targeted powers, with authority for the CFTC over spot crypto markets given as one example.

On the agencies themselves, he argued that regulators already have "ample authority" to act. He added that the administration had needed to hold them back while Congress was working on the bill, so that rulemaking did not run ahead of the legislative process. With the bill stalled, that restraint no longer applies, and the SEC and CFTC have since pushed forward with crypto rules of their own.

Not everyone views agency action as an adequate substitute. House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill, a Republican from Arkansas, says those efforts fall short of what the legislation would have achieved. The distinction matters to companies planning long-term investments: a statute passed by Congress is harder to undo than rules and guidance issued by regulators, which can be revised when leadership at an agency changes.

Witt nonetheless expressed confidence in the people now in charge. He said SEC Chair Paul Atkins and CFTC Chair Michael Selig are committed to moving markets on-chain. He framed the stakes in terms of American competitiveness, arguing that capital will go where it is treated best.

6. A Democratic Congress and a generational divide

The political ground has shifted since the September vote. Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress in the midterm elections, an outcome that might be expected to darken the outlook for an industry that had aligned itself closely with the Trump administration's agenda.

Witt rejected that reading. He said he is "not bearish on the industry overall," pointing out that the regulators and the president remain in place regardless of who controls Congress. Democrats, for their part, are said to be preparing a broader market structure bill of their own, which suggests the subject will stay on the legislative agenda even if the Clarity Act itself does not return.

He also argued that the dividing line on crypto is changing. Opposition, in his view, is becoming a matter of generation more than party. He singled out Senator Elizabeth Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, as someone who will oppose anything seen as favorable to crypto.

By contrast, he said younger lawmakers on both sides treat crypto as part of the country's financial infrastructure. He named two Democrats as examples: Senator Angela Alsobrooks of Maryland and Senator Ruben Gallego of Arizona. If that description holds, future negotiations could depend less on which party holds the majority and more on which members within each party take the lead.

7. What the outcome means for the industry

For crypto companies, the practical consequence of Witt's forecast is that the rules they operate under will arrive through a different channel than the one they spent years lobbying for. Rulemaking and guidance can move faster than legislation, and the agencies are already advancing their own proposals. The trade-off is durability, the concern that French Hill's criticism points to.

The Clarity Act was meant to settle the framework for crypto markets in one piece of law. Without it, the answers will come in stages, from two agencies working through their own processes, possibly supplemented by narrower grants of power from Congress such as spot market authority for the CFTC.

Witt's competitiveness argument is aimed at that uncertainty. His position is that the United States is competing with other jurisdictions for capital and for the businesses that deploy it, and that a failure to legislate carries a cost even when regulators are willing to act. That is the sense in which he called the defeat a failure of leadership and not simply a lost vote.

8. What comes next for Witt and for market structure rules

Several developments are now worth watching. The SEC and CFTC are continuing with their own crypto rules, and the direction Atkins and Selig take will define the regulatory picture in the absence of a statute. In Congress, attention turns to whether elements of the Clarity Act are attached to larger packages and to the broader market structure bill Democrats are said to be planning.

Witt himself is between roles. He left the administration in October and said he has held talks with crypto firms, venture capital firms and defense companies. He hopes to announce his next move in the coming weeks.

His remarks in London amount to the most detailed account so far, from the official who led the effort, of how the bill was lost: a negotiation that resolved most of its policy disputes, an ethics fight that could not be contained, and an election calendar that left no room for a second try.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY