1. Democrats Challenge the CFTC Prediction Markets Directive
Democrats on the Senate Agriculture Committee wrote to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) on Monday, November 16, asking it to withdraw a directive that told Kalshi and other prediction market platforms to stop blocking users in states that have banned their contracts. The senators argue that the CFTC prediction markets order collides with court rulings that require those blocks.
The letter puts lawmakers who oversee the agency in direct opposition to its chairman, Michael Selig, on one of the most contested questions in American financial regulation: whether a federally supervised exchange offering contracts on sports and other events can be shut out of a state under that state's gambling laws. The regulator says it cannot. A growing number of judges have said, at least for now, that it can.
The signatories include Senator Adam Schiff of California and Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan. Both represent states where courts have already limited what prediction platforms may offer, a point the letter leans on heavily. Their message to the commission was blunt. "Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed," the senators wrote.
2. What Did the CFTC Tell Prediction Markets to Do?
The agency instructed the exchanges it regulates to end geofencing, giving them 30 days either to disregard state-level restrictions or to explain why they were unable to do so. Geofencing is the practice of using a customer's location to switch off access to a product in a specific territory. For prediction markets, it has become the standard way to comply when a state or a court declares certain contracts off limits.
The practice has spread as more states have gone to court against the industry. Each new ruling or enforcement action tends to produce another patch of the map where a platform's sports contracts, or sometimes its entire offering, are unavailable. The result is a product that looks different depending on where a customer happens to be standing.
In the commission's view, that patchwork is not merely inconvenient but unlawful. Earlier this month, the CFTC told its regulated venues that restricting access state by state violates federal derivatives law, and it set the one-month clock for them to operate across all 50 states. The goal is a single national market with no state carve-outs.
The difficulty is that several platforms are geofencing because judges ordered them to. An exchange that follows the regulator's instruction in those places risks defying a court, while one that keeps the blocks in place risks being told by its own supervisor that it is breaking federal law. The senators' letter is aimed squarely at that bind.
3. The Court Orders at the Heart of the Senators' Complaint
Judicial rulings, rather than policy preferences, form the backbone of the Democrats' argument. The letter notes that courts have ordered platforms to stop offering some contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as on the land of two tribes in California, and that those orders imposed geofencing as the means of compliance.
More broadly, the senators pointed out that many courts have halted the industry's activity in states whose gambling statutes permit such bans. The CFTC is in active litigation against states over this question, and several federal appeals courts have come down on the states' side. Federal courts have not spoken with one voice, however, and the conflicting decisions make it likely that the dispute will end up before the Supreme Court.
Against that backdrop, the lawmakers wrote that the commission "now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts" while the cases are still being fought. Their request is narrower than a permanent retreat: they want the CFTC to pull back its demand until the litigation has run its course.
The inclusion of tribal land in the letter is notable. Tribal governments have their own stake in the question because gaming on their land is governed by its own legal framework, and the senators frame the CFTC's order as undermining tribal law as well as state law.
4. Why Selig Says Federal Law Overrides State Bans
Chairman Selig's position rests on preemption, the legal doctrine under which a federal statute displaces state rules that conflict with it. Kalshi, Polymarket and their peers are registered with the CFTC as designated contract markets, or DCMs, the same category of regulated exchange that lists futures on commodities and financial instruments. Selig argues that because these venues are federally regulated, state authorities cannot use gambling laws to restrict them.
He has tied that argument to the purpose of the statute his agency administers. Derivatives markets "must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale" to meet the goals of the Commodity Exchange Act, Selig has said. Under that reading, an event contract listed on a DCM is a federally regulated derivative wherever the customer lives, and a state that walls it off is intruding on federal territory.
States see the same products differently. To their gaming regulators and attorneys general, a contract that pays out on the result of a game is a sports bet, whatever the legal wrapper, and offering it without a state license is illegal gambling. That clash of definitions is what the courts are being asked to resolve, and it explains why the same platform can be a lawful exchange in the eyes of Washington and an unlicensed sportsbook in the eyes of a state capital.
5. Louisiana and Arkansas Become the Newest Fronts
Louisiana is the most recent state to move toward a ban, after a judge allowed state officials to prohibit prediction market contracts. The state's stance is not new: nearly a year ago, the Louisiana Gaming Control Board said it "considers purported sporting event contracts" to be illegal gambling.
A temporary restraining order in the Louisiana case named a broad list of companies, including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini and Crypto.com, among others. The breadth of that list shows how far event contracts have spread beyond specialist venues into mainstream brokerage and crypto trading apps. The CFTC sued to stop the order, and Crypto.com and other companies have sought to join the agency's action.
Selig responded to the state's emergency lawsuit in sharp terms, calling it "naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt." He argued that Louisiana has long permitted event contract trading and should continue to allow it while the dispute is decided.
Arkansas has also been drawn in. The state sued Kalshi on November 4, accusing it of running an illegal gambling operation, and the CFTC has since filed its own suit against Arkansas. That brings the number of states the commission has sued in defense of its jurisdiction to roughly a dozen. Arkansas carries added political weight because it is the home state of Senator John Boozman, the Republican who chairs the Senate Agriculture Committee.
6. A Commission With One Commissioner and a Shifting Committee
Oversight politics give the letter more force than a routine complaint from the minority party would normally carry. The Senate Agriculture Committee has jurisdiction over the CFTC, and the Democrats who signed the letter are set to take the committee's majority in less than two months. The lawmakers pressing the agency to reverse course will soon control its hearings and its nominees.
The agency itself is unusually thin at the top. The CFTC is designed to be led by five commissioners, but Selig is currently the only one. Decisions as consequential as ordering exchanges to operate in every state are therefore being made by a commission of one, which is part of why the senators describe the directive as a "unilateral decision."
The White House has moved to fill two of the vacant seats. It nominated Nathan Anonick, a Republican staff member on the Senate Agriculture Committee, and Matthew Rowland, a Democratic pick who previously served as a senior adviser to a Democratic commissioner.
7. What the Standoff Means for Platforms and Their Users
For the exchanges, the immediate problem is practical. The 30-day window set by the CFTC is running, and each platform must decide whether to lift its location blocks, keep them, or tell the regulator why it cannot comply. In Michigan, Nevada, Washington and the affected tribal areas in California, the answer to that last question is a court order.
For customers, the outcome determines whether the same app offers the same markets nationwide. A user in a state with an active ban currently sees a restricted menu or none at all. If the CFTC's view prevails, those limits would disappear; if the states prevail, the patchwork could grow as more of them follow Louisiana and Arkansas into court.
For crypto companies, the stakes are rising as well. Coinbase, Gemini, Crypto.com and Robinhood were all named in the Louisiana restraining order, which means the fight over event contracts now reaches firms whose core business is digital asset trading rather than prediction markets alone.
8. What Happens Next
The nearest date on the calendar is Tuesday, November 17, when the Senate Agriculture Committee is scheduled to hold confirmation hearings for Anonick and Rowland. The session gives the senators who signed the letter a public forum to raise the geofencing directive with the people who may soon share the commission with Selig.
Beyond that, the 30-day deadline the CFTC gave exchanges will arrive, and platforms will have to show how they intend to reconcile the regulator's instruction with the injunctions that bind them. The CFTC's lawsuits against Louisiana, Arkansas and the other states will continue in parallel.
The larger question of whether the Commodity Exchange Act overrides state gambling law is unlikely to be settled quickly. With federal courts divided and appeals courts in several cases siding with the states, the senators expect the matter to be resolved through the Supreme Court. Until then, they want the directive off the table.
