1. A Senate Hearing Puts CFTC Prediction Markets Policy Under the Microscope
Matthew Rowland, the Democratic nominee for a seat on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), told the Senate Agriculture Committee on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, that the agency should "think long and hard" about whether prediction markets serve the public interest. Neither he nor Republican nominee Nathan Anonick directly opposed the CFTC's current approach to the industry.
The two men are President Donald Trump's picks to fill vacancies on a commission that currently has a single sitting member, Chairman Mike Selig. Both previously worked on the staff of the same committee that is now considering their confirmation, though on opposite sides of the aisle, and both were received warmly by the senators questioning them.
For more than an hour, the nominees fielded questions about the future of the derivatives regulator. Lawmakers pressed them on event contracts, on the steep reduction in the agency's workforce, on the need to restore a full slate of commissioners, and on whether businesses linked to the president's family would be treated like any other regulated firm. Most of the senators who attended were Democrats.
2. What Did the CFTC Nominees Say About Prediction Markets?
Rowland questioned whether the industry delivers a public benefit, while Anonick described the matter as legally unsettled and said he would follow the courts. Neither nominee took a firm position against the way the commission has handled these products so far.
Rowland grounded his answer in the statute. Federal law, he noted, instructs the CFTC to assess the public interest when it comes to certain event contracts, which are derivatives that pay out based on whether a specified event takes place. In his view, the agency needs to weigh that public interest carefully against the economic usefulness of the contracts, and he encouraged the commission to "think long and hard" about how the two considerations balance.
That framing matters because it points to a tool the agency already has. A regulator that takes the public interest test seriously could, in principle, apply more scrutiny to individual categories of contracts without abandoning its claim to oversee the sector. Rowland did not say which contracts, if any, he believes fail the test, and he stopped short of criticizing the agency's broader stance.
Anonick, who served on the committee's Republican staff, took a more cautious line. He said the legal uncertainty surrounding prediction markets makes them a complicated question and committed to abiding by any Supreme Court decision that settles it. He also characterized the subject as "very charged" and "emotional."
The CFTC has proposed rules written specifically for the emerging industry. Rowland said he hopes to take part in shaping those rules if he is confirmed, which would give a commissioner who has openly raised the public interest question a direct hand in the final text.
The contrast between the two answers was one of emphasis more than direction. Rowland signaled that the statute's public interest language should play an active role in the agency's decisions, and Anonick signaled that the judiciary should set the boundaries first.
3. Why Are Prediction Markets Fighting in Court?
Prediction market operators are in court because states argue their products are gambling that falls under state law, while the companies and the CFTC maintain that federally regulated derivatives exchanges are exempt from those laws. The outcome will determine whether the business model can operate nationwide.
Platforms including Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase are engaged in what amounts to an existential legal battle. Many states have filed lawsuits alleging that the contracts offered on these venues violate state gambling statutes. Some federal courts have sided with that view, treating the business as comparable to a casino and therefore subject to state regulation.
The companies reject that characterization. Their position, shared by the CFTC, is that registration as a federal derivatives exchange places them under the commission's authority and outside the reach of state gambling rules. One federal court has agreed with that argument, leaving the judiciary divided on the central question.
The agency has not stayed on the sidelines. The CFTC has gone to court itself to defend its authority over prediction markets, in addition to drafting the tailored rules that Rowland wants to help write. With lower courts reaching conflicting conclusions, Anonick's reference to a possible Supreme Court ruling reflects a widely held expectation that the dispute may ultimately need to be resolved at the highest level.
For traders and for the crypto companies that have entered the business, the stakes are practical. A ruling that state law governs would expose the platforms to a patchwork of licensing regimes and outright prohibitions. A ruling that federal law controls would leave the CFTC as the primary gatekeeper, which is why the views of incoming commissioners carry weight.
4. Senator Tina Smith Rejects the 'Emotional' Label
Anonick's description of the debate drew an immediate objection from Senator Tina Smith, a Minnesota Democrat. She disputed the idea that the controversy is driven by emotion and said it is a legal question.
In Smith's telling, the issue rests on the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act and on the right of states to regulate sports betting. The Indian Gaming Regulatory Act is the federal law that governs gaming conducted by tribal nations, and tribes, like states, have a stake in whether nationally available event contracts on sporting outcomes can bypass the frameworks they operate under.
The exchange illustrated the divide the nominees will inherit. One side sees prediction markets as financial instruments properly supervised by a federal derivatives regulator. The other sees them, at least in part, as wagering products that Congress and the states have long regulated through separate channels. Smith's comments made clear that some committee members regard the second view as a matter of settled legal rights, not sentiment.
5. A Smaller Agency With a Larger Mandate
Staffing was the other recurring theme. One lawmaker pointed out that the CFTC has shed roughly a quarter of its previous workforce under Selig and amid the Trump administration's campaign to shrink the federal payroll.
That contraction has come while the agency's responsibilities have grown substantially. The commission's jurisdiction now extends to prediction markets and to crypto, two fast-moving areas that add to its traditional oversight of futures, swaps and other derivatives. Both Rowland and Anonick said they were open to adding staff as needed.
The mismatch between resources and responsibilities is central to the debate over event contracts. Supervising exchanges that list contracts on elections, sports and other real-world outcomes requires surveillance, enforcement and legal staff, and the same is true of the crypto markets now within the agency's reach. A regulator defending its jurisdiction in court while drafting new rules and policing new products is doing so with about three-quarters of the people it once had.
The nominees also agreed that the commission itself should be fully populated. The law provides for five commissioners, yet Selig is currently the only one. Anonick said "a full commission is the best approach to sound, durable policy," and Rowland likewise supported filling the empty seats.
The composition of the commission affects how lasting its decisions are. Rules adopted by a single chairman can be portrayed as the product of one person's judgment, and they may be easier for a future commission to reverse. Policies debated and voted on by a bipartisan panel tend to be regarded as more stable, a point that is especially relevant when the agency is writing first-of-their-kind rules for event contracts and digital assets.
6. Questions Over the Trump Family's Ties to the Industry
The hearing closed with a pointed line of questioning from Senator Raphael Warnock, a Georgia Democrat, about the president's personal business connections to prediction markets. He highlighted the direct involvement of the president's son, Donald Trump Jr., in the sector.
Warnock cited reports that political leaders at the CFTC have prevented senior career officials from investigating firms that have business dealings with the Trump family. He then asked the nominees whether a company's ties to the president or his relatives should have any bearing on how the commission treats it.
Rowland answered no. The law, he said, has to be enforced fairly and without fear or favor. Anonick gave a similar response, agreeing that the law should apply equally and fairly to everyone, regardless of who is involved.
Those commitments will be tested if the two are confirmed. Commissioners vote on enforcement actions and rulemakings, and their willingness to treat politically connected firms the same as any other registrant will be watched closely by lawmakers who raised the concern.
7. What Comes Next for the Nominees and the Rules
Confirmation appears likely. Trump nominated Rowland and Anonick last week as candidates who already had the backing of lawmakers, and the pair are widely expected to be approved before the current session of Congress ends.
Once seated, they would join Selig and bring the commission to three members, still short of the five the law envisions. Their arrival would nonetheless end the period in which a lone chairman has steered the agency through an expansion of its remit.
The most immediate policy question in front of them is the proposed rulebook for prediction markets. Rowland has signaled that he intends to press the public interest question as that work proceeds, while Anonick has indicated that he will look to the courts, and ultimately the Supreme Court, for direction on where federal authority ends and state authority begins.
Until those rules are finished and the litigation is resolved, platforms such as Kalshi, Polymarket and Coinbase will continue to operate under conflicting court decisions, with their federal regulator defending its jurisdiction in some courtrooms while states challenge it in others.
