Regulation•

Coinbase Backs the CFTC's Plan to Define Event Contracts as Swaps but Wants the Word 'Including' Kept So Crypto Markets Are Not Left Out

In a November 18 letter, Coinbase endorsed the CFTC's proposal to write event contracts into the swap definition and asked that its list of examples stay open-ended.

Written By :MINRK
Coinbase Backs the CFTC's Plan to Define Event Contracts as Swaps but Wants the Word 'Including' Kept So Crypto Markets Are Not Left Out

Photo by Margaret Giatras on Unsplash

1. A CFTC crypto question inside a prediction market rule

Coinbase told the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in a comment letter dated November 18, 2026 that it "strongly supports" the agency's proposal to write event contracts into the federal definition of a swap. The exchange attached one request: that the regulator state plainly that the proposal's examples of sports, politics, culture and weather do not form a closed list, so that contracts tied to crypto remain covered.

The letter was addressed to CFTC Secretary Christopher Kirkpatrick and carried two signatures from Coinbase: Julia Hueckel, the company's director of regulatory policy, and David Shafer, director and associate general counsel for institutional legal. It arrived on the final day of the proposal's 30-day comment period.

For readers following CFTC crypto policy, the filing stands out less for its support than for the drafting points it raises. Coinbase is asking the agency to settle not only whether event contracts are swaps, but how the rule describes them and from what date the law is understood to have applied.

2. What did the CFTC propose?

The CFTC proposed to state explicitly that event contracts fall within the federal swap definition, naming contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather as examples. The notice appeared in the Federal Register on October 19, which opened a comment window that closed on November 18.

An event contract is a derivative whose payout depends on whether a specified event occurs. A trader takes a position on one side of a question with a defined outcome, and the contract settles when the answer is known. These products are the building blocks of prediction markets, where prices shift with traders' views on how likely an outcome is.

A swap, in broad terms, is a derivative agreement in which the parties exchange payments based on the value of something else or on the occurrence of some outcome. Writing event contracts into that definition would place them, by name, among the instruments the CFTC supervises, leaving less room for argument about whether the agency's authority reaches them.

The proposal had broad backing inside the agency. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig voted in favor, and no commissioner voted against it. Alongside the proposal, the agency issued a companion interim rule stating that casino-style gambling products are not swaps. Coinbase backed that interim rule separately.

The pairing of the two measures draws a line from both directions. One says what belongs inside the federal derivatives framework; the other says what stays outside it. For exchanges and their customers, the location of that line determines which regulator has authority over a given product and which body of law applies to it.

3. A question left open since Dodd-Frank

The underlying issue is older than prediction markets in their current form. Austin Campbell, a crypto podcast host, described the question of what counts as a swap as one "created with the passage of Dodd-Frank" and never resolved. Dodd-Frank is the 2010 financial reform law that brought swaps under federal oversight.

Campbell said the area has operated on "many sort of informal understandings and zero formal understanding." He summed up the unresolved problem in a single question: "When is something a swap and when is it not a swap?"

That gap has practical consequences. A product classified as a swap is subject to federal derivatives law and to the CFTC's supervision. A product that is not a swap may be treated under other regimes. When the classification is a matter of informal understanding, firms that list such contracts and the people who trade them operate without a firm answer about which rules govern. The CFTC's proposal is an attempt to supply a formal answer for event contracts.

4. Why Coinbase wants the list of examples left open

The four categories named in the proposal do not include crypto, and that omission is the focus of Coinbase's main request. The company argued that a closed list "would provide less certainty" and would invite negative inferences about legitimate products that fall outside the named categories.

A negative inference is a familiar risk in legal drafting. When a rule lists specific items, a reader may conclude that anything not listed was deliberately excluded. If the swap definition were read as covering only contracts on sports, politics, culture and weather, a contract on the price of a digital asset or another subject could be argued to sit outside it, even if it works in exactly the same way.

To prevent that reading, Coinbase asked for two things. First, it wants the CFTC to retain the word "including" in the rule text, which signals that the categories that follow are illustrations. Second, it asked the agency to say in the preamble, the explanatory section that accompanies a rule, that the examples create neither a closed set nor a presumption against other categories.

The letter also makes the affirmative case for crypto. It describes crypto-related event contracts as representative of products where investors seek price discovery, hedging and informational value. Those three functions are the traditional justifications for derivatives markets: they help establish what something is worth, allow participants to offset risks they already carry, and produce prices that convey information to the wider public.

5. Confirmation of existing law, not a new start date

Timing is the second drafting point Coinbase pressed. The company's position is that the Commodity Exchange Act, the federal statute governing derivatives, already covers event contracts. On that view, the rule should be framed as confirming what the law has said all along, and not as turning these contracts into swaps only from the day the rule takes effect.

The distinction matters for anything that happened before the rule. If the regulation is read as creating swap status on its effective date, contracts offered earlier could be characterized as having existed outside federal derivatives law during that earlier period. If it is read as confirmation, the same contracts were under the federal framework from the start.

Coinbase tied this argument to the present legal environment. The letter points to state enforcement actions and to federal court rulings that have gone in different directions as sources of uncertainty for exchanges and for customers. A rule framed as confirmation would give companies facing such disputes a clearer statement from the federal regulator about the status of the contracts involved.

6. The cost-benefit request and the role of the states

A further request concerns the analysis that supports the rule. Federal regulators set out the expected costs and benefits of a regulation when they adopt it. Coinbase asked the CFTC to state that its cost-benefit analysis would still hold even if a court were to find that states regulate sports and other event contracts.

The request is aimed at durability. The tension between federal and state authority is already playing out in the enforcement actions and divided rulings the letter cites. By asking the agency to address that scenario in advance, Coinbase is seeking a rule whose reasoning does not depend on one particular outcome in that contest, and which therefore would be harder to unsettle if a court sided with a state.

Read together with the request on framing, this shows where the company sees the main risk to the proposal. Its concern is not opposition inside the CFTC, where no commissioner voted against the measure, but the possibility that litigation elsewhere narrows or complicates what the federal rule accomplishes.

7. Coinbase's stake in the outcome

Coinbase is commenting as a participant in the market the rule would govern. The company owns Coinbase Derivatives, an exchange registered with the CFTC, and it offers event contracts to customers nationwide through its brokerage arm.

That position explains the emphasis on crypto. A platform whose customers came to trade digital assets has an obvious interest in event contracts linked to those assets, and in a federal definition that leaves no doubt such contracts qualify. A rule that named four categories and was later interpreted as exhaustive would place the products closest to Coinbase's core audience in the least certain position.

It also explains the interest in nationwide clarity. A business offered across the country is exposed to the differing views of individual states. A federal definition that clearly covers its contracts, described as a confirmation of existing law, supports the company's ability to offer the same products to customers everywhere under a single regulator.

8. What happens next

With the comment period closed on November 18, the proposal moves to the stage where the CFTC reviews the submissions it received and decides on the final wording. Under the standard federal rulemaking process, an agency publishes a proposal, collects public comments for a set period, and then weighs those comments before adopting a final version, which may differ from the draft. Letters such as the one from Coinbase are the formal channel through which companies and members of the public can seek changes to the text or to the explanation that accompanies it.

Three elements of the final text will show how far Coinbase's requests were taken up: whether the word "including" remains in front of the listed categories, whether the preamble says the examples are not a closed set, and whether the rule is presented as confirming that the Commodity Exchange Act already reaches these contracts. The treatment of the cost-benefit analysis in the event of an adverse court finding on state authority is a fourth point to watch.

Until the agency acts, the status Campbell described remains in place: a market operating on informal understandings while the formal answer to when a contract is a swap is still being written.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY