Mentioned in This Article
1. Copper Proposal Fails by a Wide Margin
A Cardano governance vote that closed on Sunday, November 15, rejected Toto Finance's request for 22 million ADA, worth about $5 million, from the network treasury to buy physical copper. Stake voting against the proposal outweighed stake voting for it by more than 140 to 1, and none of the seven constitutional committee members supported it.
The result settles one of the more unusual spending requests the network's treasury has received since Cardano moved to on-chain governance. Instead of funding developer tools, infrastructure or ecosystem marketing, Toto Finance asked the community to put a meaningful share of its pooled funds into an industrial metal held in a warehouse, then convert that metal into blockchain tokens.
The scale of the defeat matters as much as the outcome. Treasury proposals often fail narrowly or stall for lack of participation. This one was turned down decisively by the delegated representatives who hold most of the network's voting power, and it was ignored or opposed by the body charged with checking whether spending requests fit the network's founding rules.
2. What Toto Finance Asked the Cardano Treasury to Fund
Toto Finance is a company that issues blockchain tokens backed by commodities. Its proposal asked for 22 million ADA, the native token of the Cardano (ADA) blockchain, to be withdrawn from the treasury and used mainly to purchase copper.
Roughly two-thirds of the requested funds were earmarked for COMEX-grade copper. COMEX is the metals futures exchange run by CME Group, and its grade standard defines the purity and form of copper that can be delivered against its contracts, which makes the label a common benchmark for institutional-quality metal. Under the plan, the copper would have been stored in a facility near New Orleans.
Once purchased, the metal was to be tokenized at a ratio of one token per pound, creating an on-chain representation of each unit held in storage. The copper would then have been kept for a period of 18 to 24 months before being sold. The proposal called for the proceeds to be returned to the Cardano treasury by the 36th month.
In effect, the plan asked the community to act as an investor in a commodity position, with Toto Finance handling the purchase, storage arrangements and tokenization. The treasury would have carried the price risk of both copper and ADA over a multiyear horizon, while the network gained a showcase for commodity-backed tokens issued on its chain.
3. How Cardano Treasury Withdrawals Are Decided
Cardano's treasury is a shared pool of ADA that grows from two sources: a portion of the transaction fees paid on the network and a share of newly issued tokens. Since the network adopted on-chain governance, ADA holders decide how that pool is spent rather than leaving the decision to a single foundation or development company.
Voting power on Cardano is weighted by stake. The more ADA a participant owns, or has had delegated to them by other holders, the more weight their vote carries. Most holders do not vote directly on each proposal. Instead, they delegate their voting power to delegated representatives, known as DReps, who cast votes on their behalf across governance actions.
Treasury withdrawals face a high bar. A request needs yes votes from 67% of the active voting stake among DReps to pass. Holders who prefer to signal distrust in the system as a whole can also delegate to a no-confidence option, which counts against approval.
A second check comes from the constitutional committee, a seven-member body that reviews whether governance actions, including spending requests, comply with Cardano's constitution. Its approval is also required for a treasury withdrawal to be enacted, which means that even a proposal with broad DRep support can be stopped if the committee does not back it.
This structure was introduced through network upgrades in 2024 and early 2025 that shifted control of key decisions, including treasury spending, from the network's founding entities to token holders and their representatives. The design deliberately separates economic judgment, which rests with stake-weighted voters, from constitutional review, which rests with the committee. Proposals therefore have to persuade a broad base of capital and survive a legal-style compliance check before any ADA leaves the treasury.
4. Inside the Cardano Governance Vote Count
The tally left little room for interpretation. On-chain voting records show that DReps cast just over 20 million ADA in favor of Toto Finance's request, while 2.86 billion ADA was cast against it. That gap is the source of the more than 140-to-1 ratio between opposing and supporting stake.
A further 131 million ADA was registered under the no-confidence option. While that stake did not vote directly for or against the copper plan, it adds to the weight that did not support approval.
Measured against the 67% threshold, the proposal fell drastically short. Of the stake that took a side on the question, Toto Finance won less than 1%. Even if every abstaining or inactive holder had somehow swung in its favor, the existing opposition alone would have made approval close to impossible.
The constitutional committee delivered the same verdict through a different route. Three of its seven members voted no, and the remaining four did not vote at all. With not a single member voting yes, the proposal had no path through the second layer of review regardless of how the DRep vote turned out.
5. Why Did Cardano Voters Reject the Copper Plan?
Voters did not issue a joint statement explaining their choices, but the economics of the proposal had already drawn scrutiny before the vote. An analysis published in October found that copper prices would have needed to rise by about 49% for the treasury to recover the ADA it put in, assuming ADA's dollar price stayed flat over the holding period.
That calculation captures the core problem for many treasury participants. The treasury is denominated in ADA, and any return from the copper position would have had to overcome not only the cost of buying, storing and insuring the metal, but also the fees attached to the arrangement, before the community came out ahead in its own unit of account.
The fee structure itself was part of the debate. Toto Finance stood to collect up to about 3.36 million ADA, roughly 15% of the total request, through a combination of technology and management fees, an execution fee and a margin applied to storage and insurance invoices. For a proposal of this size, that share is substantial.
Monty Metzger, the founder of Toto Finance, said in October that the company takes no profit from the proposal. Voters were left to weigh that assurance against the fee schedule laid out in the request and the long period over which the treasury's funds would have been tied up in a single commodity.
6. Pressure on a Capped Treasury Budget
The vote also has to be read against the limits Cardano holders have placed on spending. The community capped treasury withdrawals at 500 million ADA for a period running through roughly July 2027, a ceiling meant to keep the pool from being drained too quickly.
By October 16, 457.4 million ADA of that allowance had already been committed to approved work. That left only a modest amount of room under the cap for the rest of the budget period, and Toto Finance's request alone would have used more than half of the remaining capacity.
In practice, approving the copper purchase would have crowded out other proposals competing for the same limited allowance, including requests for software development, tooling and other ecosystem work. With the request rejected, that headroom remains available for other uses until the cap period ends.
7. A Test Case for Real-World Assets on Cardano
The vote was one of the few occasions on which a crypto network's community has been asked directly whether shared funds should be placed into a physical commodity. Tokenized real-world assets, from government bonds to precious metals, have become a major theme across the industry, and many blockchain ecosystems are competing to host them.
Toto Finance's pitch combined both ideas: the treasury would provide the capital, and the network would gain tokens backed by warehoused metal. The outcome suggests that Cardano's voters, at least for now, draw a firm line between supporting real-world asset projects on their chain and using communal funds to take on the underlying commodity exposure themselves.
The result also shows how Cardano's two-layer governance design works in practice. DReps rejected the request on economic grounds by an overwhelming margin, and the constitutional committee offered no support. Either outcome alone would have been enough to stop the withdrawal.
For other projects preparing treasury requests, the episode offers a clear signal about what voters scrutinize. Expected returns measured in ADA, the share of funds flowing to the proposer as fees, the length of time capital would be locked up and the claim a request makes on a capped budget all appear to weigh heavily. Proposals that ask the treasury to carry investment risk on behalf of the community are likely to face a far higher burden of proof than requests to fund open software or shared infrastructure.
8. What Comes Next for Toto Finance
It is not yet clear whether Toto Finance will return with a revised plan. The company had not answered questions sent the previous week, including whether it intends to resubmit the proposal, by the time the outcome was reported.
Any new version would face the same thresholds: support from 67% of active DRep voting stake and approval from the constitutional committee, all within whatever room is left under the 500 million ADA cap that runs through about July 2027. For now, the copper stays out of the Cardano treasury.
