Mentioned in This Article
1. Nic Carter takes aim at the Bitcoin treasury strategy
Nic Carter, a general partner at Castle Island Ventures, said in an interview on October 27, 2026, that most public companies holding Bitcoin (BTC) as a core treasury asset give investors little that a spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund does not already provide. In his view, the ETF is the cleaner route to the asset, while treasury stocks layer on corporate risk.
The critique goes to the heart of the Bitcoin treasury strategy that has spread across public markets over the past several years. These companies, often grouped under the label digital asset treasury firms or DATs, sell their shares on the promise that owning them means owning Bitcoin plus something extra. Carter's argument is that, for the majority of them, that extra is difficult to identify.
2. What are Bitcoin treasury companies?
Bitcoin treasury companies are publicly listed businesses that hold Bitcoin on their balance sheets as a central part of their corporate strategy, rather than as a small side position. For some of them, accumulating Bitcoin has effectively become the main business, with the original operating company playing a secondary role.
Their appeal to shareholders rests on a claim of added value. The pitch is that a share in such a company offers exposure to the price of Bitcoin together with something an investor could not get simply by buying the coin. That something might be management skill in raising capital, a strategy for growing the amount of Bitcoin attributable to each share, or yield generated from the holdings.
Carter's skepticism focuses precisely on that additional layer. If it does not exist, or if it is outweighed by the costs and risks of the corporate wrapper, then the investor is paying for a more complicated version of a product that is now widely available in simpler form.
3. Why Carter sees spot ETFs as the cleaner option
Carter's central point is that a spot Bitcoin ETF strips exposure down to its essentials. The fund holds the asset and tracks its price. There is no corporate strategy to evaluate, no executive team making capital allocation decisions, and no balance sheet carrying debt that could come due at an inconvenient moment.
Buying shares in a treasury company is a different proposition. An investor takes on the company's management, its decisions about how to raise and deploy capital, any borrowing it has done to fund Bitcoin purchases, and the running costs of operating a listed business. Each of those is an additional source of risk sitting on top of the price risk of Bitcoin itself.
From that perspective, the corporate structure is not a neutral container. It can amplify returns if management executes well, but it can also introduce losses that have nothing to do with how Bitcoin performs. For an investor whose goal is simply to own Bitcoin through a brokerage account, Carter suggests the ETF does the job with fewer moving parts.
4. How a spot Bitcoin ETF works
A spot Bitcoin ETF is a fund that buys and holds actual Bitcoin, typically through a regulated custodian, and issues shares that trade on a stock exchange. The share price is designed to follow the value of the fund's Bitcoin holdings closely, minus a management fee.
Authorized participants, usually large trading firms, can create or redeem shares in exchange for cash or the underlying asset. That mechanism helps keep the fund's market price close to the value of the Bitcoin it holds, which is one reason ETFs rarely trade at the kind of sustained discounts or premiums seen in corporate vehicles.
For investors, the practical result is predictability. They know what the fund owns, what it charges and how it is supposed to behave. There is no strategy that can change direction after a board meeting, which is precisely the simplicity Carter points to when he describes the ETF as the cleaner option.
5. How Strategy built the template
The treasury company model traces back to Michael Saylor's MicroStrategy, now known as Strategy and traded under the ticker MSTR. The business intelligence software company began converting its cash reserves into Bitcoin and then turned to raising money through share sales and debt to buy more, eventually becoming the largest corporate holder of the asset.
Strategy's success in attracting investors inspired a wave of imitators. Companies across different industries and countries adopted similar playbooks, announcing Bitcoin purchases and repositioning themselves as vehicles for exposure to the asset.
As of November 2026, the sector remains highly concentrated. Strategy's holdings dwarf those of most rivals, and its scale gives it a dominant position in a field where many followers hold comparatively modest amounts of Bitcoin.
6. What ETFs changed for treasury firms
Before spot Bitcoin ETFs became available in the United States, investors who wanted Bitcoin exposure through an ordinary brokerage account had few straightforward options. Treasury stocks were among the most accessible. Shares in a company holding Bitcoin could sit in a standard brokerage or retirement account alongside other equities, which made them attractive to investors who could not or would not buy Bitcoin directly on a crypto exchange.
That role helped justify the existence of the treasury company model. Even if the corporate wrapper carried extra risks, it solved a real access problem for a large class of investors.
Spot ETFs filled that gap. Once regulated funds holding Bitcoin directly were listed on major exchanges, investors gained a simple, familiar product that offered the same brokerage-account convenience without the corporate layer. As a result, treasury firms lost much of the advantage that had made them appealing in the first place, and the burden shifted to them to prove they offer something beyond access.
7. The market discount problem
Scrutiny of treasury companies intensified through 2025 and 2026, centering on two related questions: why many of these firms trade at a discount to the value of the Bitcoin they hold, and whether they can deliver better results than owning Bitcoin directly.
A company's net asset value, or NAV, in this context is broadly the market value of its Bitcoin holdings adjusted for its liabilities. When a treasury firm's shares trade below that figure, the market is effectively saying the company is worth less than the coins it owns. A persistent discount of that kind suggests investors view the corporate structure as a cost rather than a source of value.
That interpretation lines up closely with Carter's argument. If the structure added meaningful value, shareholders would be expected to pay at least the value of the underlying Bitcoin, and possibly a premium. When they consistently pay less, it signals doubt about management, leverage, overhead or the sustainability of the strategy.
8. Yield strategies draw skepticism
Some treasury companies have tried to justify premium valuations by generating yield on their Bitcoin, through lending, structured products or other income strategies. The idea is to offer shareholders a return that a passive ETF cannot match.
Those efforts have attracted their own critics, who see uncomfortable parallels with earlier Bitcoin yield schemes. The crypto industry has seen lending platforms and yield products promise steady returns on Bitcoin deposits, only for some of them to collapse when market conditions turned and counterparties failed. That history makes investors wary of any structure that puts the underlying asset to work in pursuit of extra income.
For yield-focused treasury firms, the challenge is to show that the additional return is real, sustainable and worth the extra risk. Until they can do that convincingly, they face the same question Carter poses to the wider sector, with an added layer of doubt.
9. Which treasury companies are most exposed?
Smaller copycat firms with modest Bitcoin holdings and no distinctive strategy look most exposed to the comparison with spot ETFs. Without scale, a track record or a clear operating edge, they struggle to explain why an investor should accept their corporate risks instead of buying a fund.
The largest players are in a stronger position to make their case. They can argue that size, experience in capital markets and a long record of executing their strategy justify the structure, even with the added complexity. Their scale may also give them access to financing options that smaller rivals cannot match.
Treasury firms continue to experiment with new capital structures and approaches in search of an edge. So far, however, clear evidence of operational value beyond preserving capital and providing Bitcoin exposure has been hard to find across most of the sector.
10. What it means for investors
Carter's critique comes down to a simple test that any investor can apply: if a treasury company cannot point to a concrete advantage over a spot ETF, the shareholder is accepting extra risk without a clear reward. Management quality, leverage, cost discipline and the realism of any yield strategy all become central to that judgment.
None of this means treasury companies cannot succeed. A firm that raises capital on favorable terms, keeps its costs under control and grows its Bitcoin holdings per share faster than dilution erodes them could still reward shareholders beyond what an ETF delivers. Carter's point is that most companies have yet to show they can do that consistently, and that the burden of proof sits with them rather than with the investor.
For the sector, the pressure is likely to sort companies into those that can demonstrate a lasting edge and those that cannot. Firms in the second group face a market that increasingly treats direct, lower-risk exposure through ETFs as the default way to own Bitcoin in a brokerage account, leaving the treasury company model to justify itself one balance sheet at a time.
