Analysis•

Carbon Arc's Kirk McKeown Wants Alternative Data Treated as an Earning Asset as AI Erodes the Hedge Fund Information Edge

Carbon Arc CEO Kirk McKeown, who ran market intelligence at Point72, says AI is cheapening alternative data and could turn corporate data into a financeable asset class.

Written By :MINRK
Carbon Arc's Kirk McKeown Wants Alternative Data Treated as an Earning Asset as AI Erodes the Hedge Fund Information Edge

Photo by 1981 Digital on Unsplash

1. A former Point72 data buyer sees a new market forming

Kirk McKeown, chief executive of alternative data company Carbon Arc and the former head of market intelligence at Steve Cohen's hedge fund Point72, said in remarks published on November 20 that artificial intelligence could turn alternative data into a new asset class for Wall Street, letting companies sell the data they generate for recurring revenue and potentially borrow against it.

His argument has two halves. The first is a warning for the hedge fund industry he worked in for years: AI is making alternative data cheaper and easier to use, which wears away an advantage that firms once paid millions of dollars to secure. The second is an opportunity for ordinary businesses, which McKeown believes are sitting on information that could become a dependable stream of income and, eventually, the basis for financing deals.

McKeown described the end state as "a new capital market" built on the structure of data. Getting there, he acknowledged, will require answers to questions about valuation, privacy, ownership and compliance that the market has not yet resolved.

2. What is alternative data in finance?

Alternative data in finance is information that sits outside the standard sources investors rely on, such as quarterly earnings reports and regulatory filings, and that can reveal how a business is performing before those official documents are published. Credit card transactions and consumer spending patterns are the classic examples.

The appeal is timing. A public company reports results only once a quarter, and by the time the numbers appear, the market has often already formed a view. A fund that can see, weeks earlier, that shoppers are spending more or less at a particular retailer can position itself ahead of the announcement. That is the edge alternative data promises.

None of this information is secret in the sense of being illegally obtained or confidential inside knowledge. The barrier has always been cost. Buying the raw data is expensive, and turning it into something a portfolio manager can act on has historically required teams of analysts, engineers and researchers to clean it, organize it and interpret it.

3. Inside the Point72 data operation

McKeown knows that expense from the buyer's side. He spent more than eight years running Point72's market intelligence operation, and before that he worked at Glenview Capital, the investment firm founded by Larry Robbins. At Point72, his job was to spend heavily on data that could help the firm's portfolio managers get ahead of the market.

The data his team acquired included credit card transactions and consumer spending information, the kinds of signals that rarely show up in a company's financial statements. The goal was to detect shifts in a business before those shifts surfaced in its earnings. That meant not only paying for the datasets themselves but also staffing the specialists needed to make sense of them.

That model, in which a large fund pays a premium for exclusive or hard-to-process information and builds an internal team to exploit it, is the one McKeown now says is due for a shake-up. In his view, the change is not simply about AI lowering the cost of research. It is about a broader restructuring of who owns data, who pays for it and how its value is captured.

4. How Carbon Arc packages data for investors and AI tools

Carbon Arc, where McKeown is now chief executive, sources transaction data from businesses. Its catalogue covers credit card spending, retail sales and healthcare claims, among other categories. The company organizes that information so it can be used both by investors and by AI tools.

Carbon Arc says its platform holds about 600 datasets. Rather than requiring customers to license an entire dataset up front, the platform lets them use AI agents to ask questions about how companies are performing and pay only for the data those queries actually draw on. The businesses that supply the data receive a share of the revenue.

That structure reflects McKeown's broader thesis. On the demand side, it lowers the cost of entry for investors who want a specific insight without committing to a large purchase. On the supply side, it creates a mechanism for the companies generating the data to earn ongoing income from it, which is the foundation of the asset class he envisions.

5. Why AI threatens the hedge fund data advantage

McKeown said AI makes the process of extracting insight from data faster and cheaper. Investors can now pull out the particular answer they need without buying a whole dataset and without employing a large team to work through it. The practical effect is that information once available mainly to the biggest, best-resourced funds is becoming accessible to a much wider group of market participants.

When more investors can see the same signals, those signals lose much of their power to generate outsized returns. An edge that depends on knowing something before others do disappears once everyone knows it at roughly the same time. That is the risk McKeown sees for hedge funds that have spent heavily to build their information advantage.

He summarized the dynamic in three words: "Alpha always moves." In investing, alpha refers to returns above what the broader market delivers, and his point is that the sources of those excess returns never stay fixed. As one advantage becomes common knowledge, the opportunity shifts somewhere else.

6. The credit card data precedent

McKeown pointed to credit card data as an example of how this cycle has already played out. Hedge funds began adopting credit card data in earnest around 2012. At the time, it offered a genuinely unusual window into consumer behavior and gave early users a real advantage.

Today the same kind of data is a routine part of investment research. What was once a differentiator has become standard equipment, used by so many firms that simply having it no longer sets anyone apart.

McKeown argues that a similar transition is now under way across alternative data more broadly, accelerated by AI. In his telling, the advantage is moving away from access, meaning the ability to obtain information others cannot, and toward judgment: knowing which questions to ask of the data and how to interpret what comes back. For investment firms, that suggests the value of their people may increasingly lie in framing and analysis rather than in the purchasing budget behind them.

7. Turning corporate data into recurring revenue

The longer-term bet McKeown is making concerns the businesses that produce data rather than the funds that consume it. Companies generate large volumes of information through their everyday operations, including payments, invoices and customer activity. McKeown believes that information could be converted into a steady source of revenue.

If a company can sell access to its data on an ongoing basis, that income starts to look like other predictable cash flows that businesses already monetize. McKeown suggested that this could, in turn, support financing arrangements backed by expected future data sales, in the same way that lenders and investors already structure deals around other income-producing assets.

"Data is an asset," he said, describing it as an "economic earning asset today." The framing matters. Most companies treat their data as a by-product of doing business or as an internal tool for improving operations. McKeown is arguing that it should be viewed as something closer to a revenue-generating holding, one that could appear in financing discussions much as other assets do.

For businesses, that would open a new way to profit from information they already produce. For capital markets, it would create a new category of collateral and a new set of cash flows to price, trade and lend against.

8. The obstacles: valuation, privacy and ownership

McKeown was clear that significant hurdles stand in the way. The most basic is that data has no standard method of valuation. Lenders and investors are comfortable financing assets whose worth can be estimated with established tools; a dataset whose value depends on who wants it, how fresh it is and what questions it can answer is much harder to price consistently.

Legal and regulatory constraints add further complications. Privacy laws limit what kinds of personal information can be collected, shared and sold. Questions of ownership, meaning who actually holds the rights to data generated by customers interacting with a business, are often unsettled. Compliance requirements also make it more difficult to sell data or to pledge it as collateral for a loan.

Because of these issues, McKeown believes clearer rules are needed before a true market for data as an asset class can take shape. Without them, the risk and uncertainty around using data as the basis for financing would likely keep many potential participants on the sidelines.

9. What the shift could mean for hedge funds and businesses

If McKeown's view proves correct, the consequences would run in two directions at once. Hedge funds could lose part of the informational advantage they have spent years and considerable sums building, as AI tools put similar insights within reach of many more investors. The firms most likely to keep an edge would be those best at asking sharp questions and interpreting the answers, rather than those with the largest data budgets.

Businesses, meanwhile, could find new ways to earn money from data they already create in the normal course of operations. Platforms such as Carbon Arc, which pay suppliers a share of revenue when their data is used, offer an early version of that model.

The bigger step, using data as the backing for financing in the way other income-producing assets are used, remains further off. Its arrival depends on progress in valuation methods and on regulators providing clearer rules around privacy, ownership and compliance. Until those pieces are in place, the idea of data as a full-fledged asset class for Wall Street remains a vision rather than a working market.

Related Articles

NEWSLETTERS

Don't miss another story.

Subscribe to the MINRK Newsletter today.

Tick the newsletters you want. No selection? You'll get MINRK Headlines.

By signing up, you will receive emails about MINRK products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

MINRK Daybook

Market analysis for crypto traders and investors.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK for Advisors

Defining crypto, digital assets and the future of finance for financial advisors.

EVERY THURSDAY

MINRK Protocol

Exploring the tech behind crypto one block at a time.

WEEKLY

MINRK Long & Short

A must read for institutions. Insights, news and analysis delivered weekly.

EVERY WEDNESDAY

MINRK Headlines

The biggest crypto news and ideas of the day.

EVERY WEEKDAY

MINRK Policy

Examining the intersection of cryptocurrency and government.

WEEKLY

MINRK Research

Join thousands of readers who rely on MINRK for data-driven insights on the latest digital asset trends.

MONTHLY